Charles has certainly had sex with brides #3 and #4. Someone made the brilliant suggestion that Charles ends up at a table with four of his ex-girlfriends at wedding #2 because it is the bride's idea -- or possibly her mother's idea -- of a perfect day.
In that case, Charles has probably slept with bride #2. That leaves bride #1 to complete the set. I have always felt that Fiona's snapping at Scarlett is not convincingly explained just as a fashion judgment -- although it is certainly that -- or just as being jealous that someone else was getting married -- although that is probably the case. It's not that she can't snap, but it seems excessive and she usually does not snap at Scarlett.
Scarlett: Oh, isn't she lovely!
Fiona: Scarlett, you're blind. She looks like a big meringue.
Fiona reacts very strongly to women that Charles has been involved with or is interested in, and I find the intensity of her reaction best explained by bride #1 being an ex-girlfriend of Charles's. Certainly there is a fashion statement, certainly Fiona may wish that she were getting married, but I feel a particular animosity in her reaction.
I think it entirely plausible that Richard Curtis has set things up so that Charles has slept with all of the brides. That certainly fits with my conception of his sense of humor and of his writing a romantic comedy that is deliberately unconventional. There are other sexual elements -- surprises you might say -- that are not made explicit but are absolutely there.
There are four of Charles's ex-girlfriends at his table at wedding #2. Adding Henrietta and Carrie, that makes a minimum of six of the nine women that he has slept with. If I am right about the first two brides, that makes eight out of nine. I wonder who the ninth could be? I wonder if it could be that years ago . . .
We hear about all of Carrie's sexual partners and there is a certain nice symmetry if we have also heard about all of Charles's.
I'm not claiming that this is true, but I do have a lot of confidence that Richard Curtis could have set things up this way and would have enjoyed doing it.
reply
share