MovieChat Forums > Scarlett (1994) Discussion > Are There 2 Different Versions of Scarle...

Are There 2 Different Versions of Scarlett?

posted 20 years ago by 8ofem
8 replies | jump to latest

I'm horribly confused here. IMDB lists a movie of Scarlett and a Mini-series of Scarlett that both seem to be the same thing with the same actors, although there's almost no info for the movie version. I have seen the mini-series version that was released by hallmark on vhs and dvd. Both of those releases show exactly what was aired on TV. However, I tried to sell my Scarlett DVD on e-bay recently, and I kept getting e-mails from people asking if it's the version that started at Melonie's funeral or not......apparently one person claims there is another version of Scarlett that starts out apparently like the original Gone With The Wind instead of just picking up immediately where Gone With The Wind left off. I'm very confused.

IS THERE ANOTHER VERSION OF THE FILM? IF SO, HOW HAVE PEOPLE SEEN IT, AND HOW CAN YOU GET A REAL COPY OF IT? Was it just released in other countries?

HELP!!!!!!!!!

[–] wwjs1984 20 years ago

I remeber when the Scarlet mini series aired on Tv in 1994 and it started at melly's funeral to my knowledge that is the only Scarlett film it never went to the movies it just came on tv and they showed in two days like they do any mini series. So I beleive there is only one version of Scarlett.

[–] Irene-08 19 years ago

There is only one version of Scarlett!

[–] sheenaman 17 years ago

yes! there are two versions. the one i ordered on amazon does not start at melly's funeral and that is the one that i am looking for as well. but that is the only one that i am able to find on dvd. please let me know if you find out where we can get this other version.

[–] 13124293 17 years ago

I bought the DVD in South Korea. My copy starts at Melly's funeral. Don't kow how to get a copy of this outside of ROK, though.

[–] 17 years ago

[deleted]

[–] sheenaman 17 years ago

KingAndrewI, does it also contain a scene when scarlett is on the boat by the rail and looking at rhett dropping off a couple of women who are to board the boat? scarlett waits in anticipation for rhett to turn around and look at her, which he finally does.

[–] morganseer 16 years ago

It must have been an error, which they now corrected. Now there's this (2006) version, with a completely different cast:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0477083/

But it doesn't seem to come highly recommended.

[–] hey_teacher 16 years ago

The 2006 movie "Scarlett" is a completely different story. IT has nothing to do with Scarlett O'Hara and Rhett Butler of Gone with the Wind.