MovieChat Forums > When a Stranger Calls Back (1993) Discussion > What do you suppose she went back for? *...

What do you suppose she went back for? *spoilers*


*spoilers*

What do you think Julia went back to her apartment for? Her gun? Her favorite robe/book/shoes?

And one other thing, what did Jim Landis do.....wait in Julia's apartment on the chance she'd return, and get her then? How could he have done it exactly though?

The clock read the wrong time. Think she may have fallen asleep there, Landis unplugged the light and the phone(how?) and then shot her as she slept? I would have thought he's cut the power, but it was intact when the ambulance arrived.


"[Success is] to know even one life has breathed easier because you have lived."
-B. Stanley

reply

I had some time to think about it after reading the message boards and then I rewatched the film.


I at first thought Julia was sucidal and that is why she went back to her apartment. but then I watched the film with my boyfriend and he told me Julia was self reliant. She went back to her apartment because she wasn't going to let Landis scare her from there.


you are right the clock was the wrong time so maybe he did turn off the light that also shared the same wall socket with the clock, I am not sure he tamper with the phone.

Maybe the bed and the lamp where knocked over because Julia tripped over these things in the dark.



reply

Actually this is much more subtle than you'd think.

Her last words are "Jill, Where are You?". Jill says the key is there, that that phrase has meaning. Julia needs Jill. Not just at the present moment of the shooting but because Jill was needed before. At her apartment.

Up until that point in the film Jill and Julia are operating under the assumption that William Landis has no idea where Jill lives or that she's involved and that she's "safe" there. We've all seen the end of the movie so we know this is false. Jill's last words are indicative of panic, she needs somebody. Why would she need somebody and not a place to stay?

Because Landis probably made an appearance. Landis only blocks the front door for Jill who he presumably is stalking to tie up a lose end. When she realized his presence was there she left immediately. The police don't believe her and she's all alone. She returns to her place for at least three reasons.

1. The gun is there.
2. She has nowhere to go that is safe.
3. When Jill comes home and finds no one there she'll come to Julia's place automatically.

The message on the note says "It's dark". The bullet wound was at her temple presumably where he shot her to make it appear as a suicide. She says it's dark because she knows he's there but she can't see him. He's camouflaged probably near her bed. She can't call Jill for help which she needs, direly, because Jill's on the road heading towards the house from the beginning. Jill on the phone call earlier gave her a list of directions for securing a house. She's repeating those because she needs a secure place to be and why would she need that? Because Jill's place is no longer secure. Landis HAD to have made an appearance if she was struggling to secure her much smaller, much more controllable apartment.

Jill also wrote in that book every time Landis came by. She may not even have known he was there at the apartment other than the fact that the lights had been disconnected. The important part is that she was trying to secure a location - which meant Jill's house wasn't safe.

Call me. Turn on the lights. Look around. Bolt the window. Clear the kitchen, clear the bathroom, clear the closet and then bolt the front door. Julia wants to repeat these steps but the first one she can't. "It's dark" means the lights have been broken.

She's shot in the middle of the room away from her bed so presumably she went to the kitchen table to retrieve the gun. Obviously Landis was waiting for this move as he waits Jill out similarly at the end. He grabs her and uses her own weapon her similar to how Jill' weapon was taken from her after a struggle - it probably went easier with Julia because Julia had no physical training.

Lastly there's one more suggestion. William Landis could've written it himself after overhearing her conversation about securing a living space.

reply

See, I interpreted the scene differently. The fact that Julia wrote "Jill, where are you?" made me think that Landis had written a note asking Julia to meet Jill at Julia's apartment- that was his way of luring Julia back to her apartment, and that would also explain why Julia wrote "Jill, where are you?" because she was expecting Jill to be there. That would also tie in with the power being out, which was why it was dark, etc.

reply

She says it's dark because she knows he's there but she can't see him. He's camouflaged probably near her bed.

That is what my boyfriend came up with. What I think it so cool is how everyone interpreters the same scenes differently.


reply