Sort of have to agree in a way. While I seldom see anyone as large as the Mama character, I do see very obese 9some morbidly so) out and about every day. They might be having to ride on those little scooters to get around stores and such, but it's rare that the very large person really elicits that much attention. It's the same with severely handicapped or mentally challenged people, all of whom I routinely see out in public every day. Most people just try politely not to stare. That's not to say there might not be the occasional snicker from a rude person, but generally, most people are more polite than to openly gawk and stare at someone, no matter what they look like (let alone even going so far as snapping photos! Of course, that being said, I have seen more than a few "let's make fun of the fat person" type videos on Youtube where someone discreetly shot with their camera phone. So it's not to say people don't make fun; only that usually they are a lot more subtle about it). But on the whole, I think most people are simply too caught up with going about their own business to worry too much about gawking at someone just because they're fat.
However, in the context of the film,the scene works in helping to heighten our sympathy for this character, especially since up to that point she has mostly been treated as comic relief. This is the scene that finaly humanizes her for us. Also, I think it is more than just that the town is turning out to see "the fat lady." In the novel, Bonnie Grape had had a bit of a reputation as the town beauty. She had broken several hearts, and enraged many wives (many of whom had husbands who all used to be in love with Bonnie). Then, over the years, as she had disappeared from view and ate herself into oblivion, there had built up this great town mystery about what had "happened" to Bonnie Grape. Thus, her moment of bravery in stepping out of her house and going into public also becomes a chance for everyone in town to satisfy their curiosity, and for the jealous women of the town to exact a little revenge.
None of this is ever really explained in the film, but I think the scene is trying to stay true to the spirit of the book, in which Endora finally gets its moment to satisfy their burning curiosity about the former town beauty and to find out if all the rumors about what had happened to her since her husband's death were really true. So really, it's not that they are staring "just because" she is a 500-pound woman, but because of who the 500-pound woman just happens to be.
http://www.allforloveblog.com
A Blogsite Dedicated to Michael Jackson
reply
share