I've lived in Central Maine all my life (nearly 50 years) and I've never encountered a road that was closed merely because it was snowing. Main roads rarely get more than an inch or two of accumulation before they get plowed anyway.
The worst I ever saw was about 20 years ago when it was snowing so hard that there was around 8 or 10" of accumulation on i95 between Orono and Newport before they had a chance to plow it. It didn't stop me from driving home, and it didn't stop most other people either. I just stayed in the tire tracks and drove at the same speed that everyone else was going. It helped that I had a 4WD truck, but there were plenty of 2WD vehicles in front of and behind me that were doing fine as well.
I looked up the writer, Danny Rubin, and he's from California. Maybe they close roads out there because of snow and he assumed that they do it everywhere, and never bothered to ask anyone if that particular plot device even made sense for the setting of the movie.
Erie County New York just had a travel ban because of heavy snow this past Sunday. All passenger and commercial vehicles were forbidden to use the roads. They even postponed an NFL playoff game.
Do you remember the blizzard of 1978? I don't know how it affected Maine but it shut down the entire state Connecticut for three whole days - only emergency vehicles and snowmobiles allowed. The storm hit so fast and hard that I ended up spending those three days at my dad's shop alone shoveling snow, watching soap operas (no cable tv there) and eating the few cans of cold Dinty Moore stew the 7-11 had left. I still wretch when I see them on market shelves.
I've heard about it, but I was only 3 years old at the time. Looking at the numbers, I don't see what the big deal was though, at least not in terms of accumulation:
Boston received a record-breaking 27.1 inches (69 cm) of snow; Providence also broke a record, with 27.6 inches (70 cm) of snow;[3] Atlantic City broke an all-time storm accumulation, with 20.1 inches (51 cm), two Philadelphia suburban towns in Chester County received 20.2 inches (51 cm) while the City of Philadelphia received 16.0 inches (41 cm).[5]
We got close to 4 feet of accumulation here on February 13, 2017 - https://i.imgur.com/WYCmOfi.jpg - which is the most I've ever seen from one storm in my life. I didn't encounter any closed roads.
For the 1978 storm it must have been the extreme wind in addition to the snow that made it such a big deal.
In any case, the conditions shown onscreen in Groundhog Day were way too mild for roads to be closed, especially every road out of town. There's hardly any snow on the road, it's not snowing very hard, and the wind isn't particularly strong.
reply share
Not only was the snow record breaking, but the amount of snow it dumped in a relatively short time was noteworthy along with the 80-100 winds at the same time.
In any case, the conditions shown onscreen in Groundhog Day were way too mild for roads to be closed, especially every road out of town. There's hardly any snow on the road, it's not snowing very hard, and the wind isn't particularly strong.
Yeah, I guess they didn't have the budget for better effects or maybe just figured no one would really pay attention. But they needed him to be stranded so it's a plot device I suppose.
I've never lived in Pennsylvania but my buddy moved from CT to VA a few years ago, and he told me when they get half an inch of snow everybody panics and they shut down everything. Meanwhile, he's laughing while doing drifting turns and donuts on the empty streets.
I've never lived in Pennsylvania but my buddy moved from CT to VA a few years ago, and he told me when they get half an inch of snow everybody panics and they shut down everything. Meanwhile, he's laughing while doing drifting turns and donuts on the empty streets.
Yeah, I've heard stories like that from people who live in places that don't get much snow. It's bizarre to me because from my earliest memories, snow was almost always a non-issue when it came to driving. I'm not saying that snow never causes accidents here, but what I mean is, my parents never let snowfall get in the way of driving somewhere.
I remember being in the family car during heavy snowfall many times as a kid, and not just for short drives in town either. A lot of times it was during a trip to Bangor at night (about a 45-minute drive from my hometown). Us kids would always pester Dad to turn on the high-beams because it made the falling snow so much more visible, like being inside a just-shaken snow globe. He would sometimes do it for a couple seconds when there were no other cars coming, long enough to shut us up (it's obviously not safe to drive in heavy snowfall for very long with your high-beams on).
reply share
Snow isn't the real issue. Freezing temp, ice and a derelect DOT is cause for a road closure and impassable conditions. Not saying this happened, I haven't watched in awhile. Happy groundhog days.
I’ve lived in the northeast my entire life, and there have definitely been highway shut downs, travel bans, state of emergencies etc. There have been times when the snow falls faster than the plows can clean it up. But with that said. You won’t necessarily get turned around, or get a ticket. They understand that people are getting off of work etc. it order for it to happen the way it does in the movie it has to be a downed tree, downed power lines, and multicar accident flooding or something like that.
I would agree that the amount of snow in the movie would’ve stopped travel anywhere that gets snow regularly.