Ahem... for all of you that screams over the "cropped widescreen"... Have you considered that the standard procedure usually is to crop top and bottom of the 1.33 ratio negative to produce the 1.85 print, or rather, ship a 1.33 print and at the cinemas matte the projector to 1.85? I'm a bit puzzled as to what you want. If it's cropped, it's probably as it was seen in cinemas and the full screen would be the non-matted print in it's entirety.
That is, if the 1.33 print weren't a pan-scan(cropped sides) of a widescreen print in the first place, and that that print then got cropped top-bottom for widescreen for the DVD. But that's just silly...
Wich one to prefer? well, I would go after the "intended ratio" wich is for me right now unknown. I'm guessing 1.85 cropped... and that's easy to do with most viewing setups.
But then again, picture quality... since I have neither dvd version I'm going to stay out of that one...
reply
share