MovieChat Forums > Single White Female (1992) Discussion > So what if she wanted a white roommate?

So what if she wanted a white roommate?


I am not sure what the big deal is if you were to feel more comfortable living with someone of the same ethnicity. I do not think it means you are racist.

reply

Well it may not make a person racist, but one has to question why would someone prefer a certain race over another in the first place? I mean what's the reasoning behind only prefering a white roommate? That has certain implications, don't you think? One implication being that the person has some preconceived notions about non white people IMO

reply

I think you two are reading something into the film's title that really isn't there. The ad Allie placed read:

SWF seeks female to share apartment in west 70s. Non-smoker professional preferred. 555-9814.

It doesn't say the roomate has to be white, it just says that she herself is white.

reply

I'm well aware of that fact, I was talking in a general sense. I was simply going off what was in the other thread about people expressing a color preference in ads for roommates.

reply

but it wouldn't be racist at all if she said she wanted a black roommate?

reply

No one said that, don't be an idiot.

reply

I think some people may prefer to live with someone of the same race because they might feel more comfortable living with someone from a similar background. While I believe people of different skin colors are all equal in every way, they tend to be different when it comes to some cultural aspects. People from similar cultures tend to be able to relate to each other more, and people who can relate to each other tend to bond more. Of course all of the things I have just said are certainly not always the case.

reply

Yeah, I'm more offended she singled out smokers.

reply

Well, as a non smoker, I certainly wouldn't want to share *my* apartment with a smoker. I don't think many people would.

Sorry, but there it is.


"Three years...I promise."

reply

I think some people may prefer to live with someone of the same race because they might feel more comfortable living with someone from a similar background. While I believe people of different skin colors are all equal in every way, they tend to be different when it comes to some cultural aspects. People from similar cultures tend to be able to relate to each other more, and people who can relate to each other tend to bond more. Of course all of the things I have just said are certainly not always the case.


Fair enough, but we both know that not everyone fits into a certain presumed culture a race has so only prefering a certain race as a roommate is assuming they would be uncomfortable or cannot relate with a non white person right? How could they possibly know that they can't relate to someone if they only single out their race in an ad (Generally speaking of course)?. I know there are cultural differences but one would think that people would be more open minded to different cultures and possibly wouldn't mind rooming with someone different to gain a new perspective. I mean, I'm kinda shocked that people don't think it's a tad prejudice that someone would list a race preference for roommate ads. Seems alittle close minded to me

reply

I agree with the first part of what you said...which is why I said it is "not always the case." However, I think it is a little "close-minded" to be inconsiderate of the fact that some people just might not feel comfortable with it. It would be nice if the world were less "prejudice" towards so-called "racist" white OR black people who would simply prefer to room with a white OR black person. I don't think there is anything wrong with it, and I don't really think it's anyone else's business, either.

reply

I am a male and would only want a single white female roommate. No one else need apply or I will take them to see the new blockbuster mega-hit "The Roommate" coming to a theater near you soon and then departing just as soon.

reply

She's a designer. It's possible that someone with darker skin would clash with the decor.

reply


I agree with the OP. Your apartment is your space, and you need to feel comfortable in it. Whether she wanted a bi-lingual 11-fingered older woman in there or simply a single white female, who cares?
Its her apartment, her choice. It doesn't mean she's racist.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

-First of all as harlemsushi said people are reading in to something that is not there, since the ad said "SWF seeks female to share apartment in west 70s. Non-smoker professional preferred. 555-9814." She doesnt say SWF seeking another single WHITE female, so whats the issue? And I agree with mushooisi and I think that the non-smoker detail is more discriminating :-p


"Death by stereo" -The Lost Boys

reply

Yes it does

reply

Single White Female refers to Allie not Hedy. She's saying SHE'S a SWF not that she's looking for one.

reply

[deleted]

In the book, the ad read: Single white female seeks same, indicating wanting a white roommate. However, in the movie, it read: Single white female seeks female, so she didn't specify the race she wanted, although it did turn out that her roommate was also white. Despite that difference between the movie and the book, when the movie originally came out, I do remember hearing some black women complaining about her wanting a white roommate and "that's what she gets" for wanting a white roommate. I guess you just can't win with some people no matter what you do. ;)

reply

Who gives a *beep*

reply

Why is this even a discussion? That's not what the ad said. What more is there to discuss?

reply

the original book it was from specified a white applicant (in the title), but the film made it clear the applicant didn't have to be white (I thought). However, yeah, I'd have concerns about the films title if I was making it.

reply