MovieChat Forums > C'est arrivé près de chez vous (1993) Discussion > So, is this the 'first' mockumentary...

So, is this the 'first' mockumentary ?


I thought the Blair witch project was -obviously I was wrong.

Anyone knows any previous ones ?

reply

Cannibal Holocaust (1980) is probably among the first, very realistic horror filmed in documentary style... and the comedy mockumentary "This Is Spinal Tap" (1984) most importantly, or Woody Allen's Zelig (1983).

I will return before you can say antidisestablishmentarianism. - Blackadder

reply

Also 'Best In Show' by makers of Spinal Tap and a recent Australian film, The Magician, similar to Man Bites Dog.






I am the night rider......i'm a fuel injected suicide machine

reply

For the additional information.


The 'GallantConversation' id is on vacation.

reply

I will check these out.
One thing though I don't think Zelig was a mocumentary.


The 'GallantConversation' id is on vacation.

reply

"One thing though I don't think Zelig was a mocumentary."

It's unlike any of Woody's other work. It's a documentary about a man who completely adapts his personality and even physical appearance to whoever he's around. But it's fake, it's a comedy. ("Zelig was held responsible for the behavior of each of the personalities he assumed. He was sued for bigamy, adultery and performing unnecessary dental extractions.") So it certainly is a mockumentary.

And the strict lord Death bids them to dance. -Seventh Seal

reply



But is not a mocumentary.It is a full story narrated within the lines of a film,a comedy as you say.

reply

check for Punishment Park (1971) I don't say that's the first pseudo-documentary, but the earlier I can think of

reply

PUNISHMENT PARK is a good one, but Peter Watkins' THE WAR GAME and CULLODEN (both made for the BBC in the 1960s) predate it.

'What does it matter what you say about people?'
Touch of Evil (Orson Welles, 1958).

reply

A much earlier fake documentary is Robert Flaherty's "Nanook of the North" (1922).

And, of course, outside of the movies there was Orsen Welles "War of the Worlds" radio broadcast in 1938, the first half of which was a fake real-time news broadcast.

reply

Welles was very fond of crossing the line between fiction and reality, Citizen Kane itself is part mockumentary; his F for Fake (1974) is definitely a mockumentary and one of the earliest, except that he unveils the trick at certain points in the narration - yet it still gets you wondering if it's real or not.

reply

Peter Greenaway's The Falls is one of the most surreal and bizarre mockumentries ever.

reply

Zelig is one hundred percent Mockumentary.

However, Woody Allen's first film, "Take the Money and Run," was actually his first mockumentary. It was made in 1969, and to my knowledge, it is the oldest Mockumentary I've ever seen. thats about 23 years earlier then this film.

So, as far as I am aware, Woody Allen made the first Mockumentary in 1969.

Also, Are we considering films that entirely mockumentary or only in part, because Cannibal Holocaust only has parts which are like that. And in that case, Orson Welles utilized Mockumentary style in Citizen Kane, with the NEWS ON THE MARCH segment.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Although not a movie, Orsen Wells certainly had War of the Worlds as well. One of the first mockumentaries to reach a large portion of the public so rapidly.

reply


You can read my answer here:http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0103905/board/thread/53728052?d=144709505&; amp;p=1#144709505


Also you don't see people going to Zelig's board and ask :"Is this a real story?"


I think we must redefine what mockumentary is.


reply

Nanook of the North (1922) was a scripted and staged "documentary" so I guess it could be considered a mockumentary.

reply


What about 'Take The Money and Run'?

reply

<i>Nanook of the North (1922) was a scripted and staged "documentary" so I guess it could be considered a mockumentary.</i>

that was the first documentary. it is not a mockumentary.

reply

that was the first documentary. it is not a mockumentary.


Sorry, but portions of Nanook of the North were staged, consequently it was not a documentary.

reply

Nor is it mockumentary.

Oh whisky, leave me alone.

reply

[deleted]

Even though it's of a completely different genre altogether, the earliest I can think of is the Eric Idle Beatles spoof The Rutles: All You Need is Cash. Although I've yet to see it, I've heard it's more or less the first of it's kind, although films like This is Spinal Tap and such have refined the style much more since then.

reply

[deleted]

Another incredible 'mockumentary' is Dadetwon which came out in '96. Difficult to believe it isn't real, even on repeat viewings.


"Illusion, Michael. A trick is something a whore does for money...or cocaine!"

reply

[deleted]

David Holzman's Diary (1967)

Take the Money and Run (1969)

The Rutles (1978)

No way is Man Bites Dog the first mockumentary

reply

Not by a long shot. The first was A Hard Day's Night (1964). It was thoroughly tongue-in-cheek, which is what distinguishes mockumentary from what others are calling "fake documentary."

One of the earliest among famous documentaries to count as "fake" (i.e. at least partly staged) is Nanook of the North (1922). Nowadays we'd insist on calling it a docudrama, not a documentary.

Ola yia tin epistimi!

reply

What about any early Abbott and Costello or The Three Stooges?

reply