Surprisingly 'dark'


When I first watched BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER three years ago (yes, I admit it, I'm often slow to catch up when it comes to movies), I wasn't really expecting anything but drivel. Moreover, since it was supposed to be a "comedy," I was expecting something unbearably and unrealistically schmaltzy.

Boy, was I wrong. BUFFY is unbearably and unrealistically UNschmaltzy.

Seriously, this is a pretty depressing film if you think about it. I know I was supposed to laugh much of the time, but I hardly did at all. L.A. in this movie comes off as a surreal, maddening, only SLIGHTLY funny corner of Hell. Even without the vampires, it would be, quite simply, a rotten place in which to live: snotty teenagers, clueless educators, parents who are downright neglectful, and sundry punks and riffraff roaming the streets. Only if you REALLY loved irony or enjoyed feeling superior to everyone around you would you want to live in this movie's world.

Plus, the story at the end turns out to be about a girl who loses everything she had cherished just a few months before, and is stuck in a thankless job for the rest of her life. If not for the "killing vampires" part, that would practically be the plot of an Italian neo-realist film.

reply

Was anyone else surprised by the movie, finding that it wasn't quite the teen comedy that it had been made out to be?

reply

Because almost everyone has seen that overrated TV show first, which was UNsurprisingly dark, and they expected this to be some dumb B-list teen comedy with lame jokes and no real scary parts.

http://i44.tinypic.com/x4ozk.jpg

reply

L.A. comes off in almost every movie as a dystopian hell-hole. That's which is only an ever so slight exaggeration of what it is. It's the reverse of how Manhattan comes off in movies, which is also a slight exaggeration.

reply

I think it all depends on where you are in your life - and, for that matter, where you're geographically located. If your family's hometown can be likened to your ethnicity, then I am half-Angeleno (mother born in L.A. in 1951). I have been to the city many times (including the part of town where this movie was set) and consider myself a pretty fair judge of it.

Growing up, I frankly hated Los Angeles. It was like an amalgamation of everything that sucked about America: looked like Des Moines (flat and boring), felt like Detroit (gangs and graffiti everywhere), and had the weather of El Paso. I indeed felt like I was living in one of those dystopian sci-fi thrillers that were so popular in the 1980s and much of the '90s. To me, the only thing to love about the city was Hollywood - and by the years of my childhood it was only a shadow of what it once was.

The funny thing is, now I am nostalgic for the L.A. I once hated. Looking back, it's become clearer to me that the city definitely had an undercurrent of vibrant glamour that I too often missed because I was focused so much on all the negative stuff. Now that Los Angeles is becoming rather more like New York, with ever more people fleeing to the suburbs of Ventura and Orange Counties and gentrification setting in at the core, I feel as if it's all shrinking somehow. It probably will never be the same again.

reply


Well, the script was written by Joss Whedon. So looking back at it, no it doesn't surprise me because it's what I've come to expect from his style of storytelling.

A blend of dark humor and light comedy.
* * *
Chapter One of A Vampire Novel
http://hubpages.com/hub/VampAnonTheRewrite

reply

[deleted]

the original script to this movie was intended to be much darker - when Joss was approached about doing this movie a few years after this was released, he agreed but only if he could have creative control which is where he screwed up with this movie - they butchered his script and turned it into a camp-fast with some horrible acting and worse dialogue..

step up or shut up!!!

reply

Wow, I haven't seen this movie in years but I remember it being pretty dark as well.

"I am the ultimate badass, you do not wanna `*beep*` wit' me!" Hudson in Aliens.

reply