James Berardinelli review - *** out of ****

https://www.reelviews.net/reelviews/batman-returns

The box office performance of Tim Burton’s 1989 Batman assured there would be sequel but Burton’s desire for greater creative control caused the production of Batman Returns to linger in development longer than Warner Brothers preferred. In addition to cycling through several variations of the screenplay (the shooting script, despite being solely credited to Daniel Waters, was actually an amalgamation of at least three separate drafts plus various uncredited rewrites), Burton was plagued with several potential defections. Michael Keaton was initially reluctant to return to the title role, although a hefty raise diminished many of his objections. Danny Elfman, miffed over the prominence of Prince’s contributions to Batman, needed personal assurances from frequent collaborator Burton before signing on the dotted line.

Of the original four ‘80s/’90s Batman movies, Batman Returns is the best, edging out the more flamboyant Batman Forever and easily moving beyond the Joker-centric Batman and the infamously awful Batman & Robin. Keaton is more comfortable in the role, both with and without the mask. Michelle Pfeiffer is a significant upgrade over Kim Basinger and, unlike with Batman’s leading lady, there are genuine sparks. Danny DeVito’s Penguin is a more nuanced villain than the bad-to-the-bone Joker and DeVito doesn’t feel the same need as Jack Nicholson to steal every scene (although Christopher Walken does a fair amount of mugging for the camera).

Batman Returns ups the ante from the first film. This time around, there are three villains instead of one. Two are staples of Batman lore: The Penguin and Catwoman. The third, Max Shreck, is a creation of the film. The screenplay provides abbreviated origin stories for Penguin (how the deformed baby Oswald Cobblepot was thrown into the sewers and raised by penguins) and Catwoman (how the meek secretary Selina Kyle escapes death with a vengeance-tinged perspective – “Life’s a bitch, now so am I.”). Shreck, a greedy, amoral businessman, needs no backstory. The Penguin and Catwoman come across as tragic, almost-sympathetic figures. Not so much for Shreck.

As for Bruce Wayne/Batman, Keaton portrays him as being haunted by the possibility that his alter-ego may be more harmful than beneficial to the people of Gotham City. Although Vicki Vale (Basinger’s character in Batman) doesn’t appear in the film, her parting words to Bruce (as relayed by him to Selina Kyle) are among the most salient bits of dialogue in the film. Had Burton and Keaton re-teamed for what became Batman Forever, this narrative element (which Joel Schumacher ignored) would likely have been pursued. Christopher Nolan came back to it in The Dark Knight Rises.

The central antagonist in Batman Returns is The Penguin, whose end-game is to kidnap and murder the first-born of every prominent citizen in Gotham City as a means of revenge for what was done to him as a child. Before implementing that plan, he spearheads a terrorist attack and then, with the backing of Shreck’s deep pockets, runs for mayor. Ultimately, he has two goals: eliminating Batman and avenging himself on Gotham City (not necessarily in that order). Meanwhile, Catwoman comes into the story tangentially. After Shreck pushes her out a window, she inexplicably survives thanks to the nurturing of a large number of cats. Thereafter, she assembles a skintight latex outfit and becomes briefly allied with The Penguin when she believes he can help her achieve her personal goal of killing Shreck.

One of the best elements of Batman Returns is the whirlwind romance between Bruce and Selina, who spar with each other in costume and dance with their masks off. The chemistry between them generates sparks and the moment when they simultaneously realize the truth about one another is priceless – probably the best scene in the movie. (“Oh my God. Does this mean we have to start fighting?”)

Although Batman Returns is tonally lighter than its predecessor, the film nevertheless exists in the shadows. It’s also weirder, an indication of Burton exerting stronger creative control. The film’s look owes a debt to German Expressionism, something made explicit in naming a character “Max Shreck,” a reference to silent film actor Max Schreck, who is best known for playing the emaciated Count Orlock in F.W. Murnau’s 1922 classic, Nosferatu. The film’s Christmas setting offers a gothic slant to the holiday, a possible foreshadowing of Burton’s upcoming collaboration with Henry Selick, The Nightmare Before Christmas, which was in production simultaneously with Batman Returns.