The doctor?


The scene with the doctor confuses me and I was wondering if someone could clear it up haha.
The doctor says to Martin that he has the 'most beautiful house on Cape Cod,' he then goes on to ask if the woman in the window (Laura) was Martins wife. If he had been in the house, surely he would of known that? Basically I'm wondering, did he ever go in the house or is Martin just jumping to conclusions? Laura's reaction confuses me even more, when he asks her about it she swears under her breath .

reply

I don't think for a single second that the Doctor had ever been in the house but that he'd often sailed past it, admiring it from a distance. However, Laura having to deny even knowing the man which I also believe to be true (anything to the contrary would have been hinted at in the script), meant nothing to martin because he invariably chose always to follow the worst case scenario where his property (his wife in this case) was concerned.

Point of fact it's even possible that Martin DID believe that the two had never crossed paths but saw this as another opportunity to exercise his control regardless and deter her from getting any ideas of that nature - keeping her on her toes as it were.

To be honest, even if Laura had had a chance meeting on the beach with the Doctor it's highly unlikely she would have invited him in for even innocent reasons. She couldn't even leave a towel hanging out of alignment to the rest in the bathroom or indeed leave a can of food out of alignment in the cupboard without Martin noticing. Look how thorough she was when she returned to the house after feigning her drowning - carefully backtracking her every step and mopping up water after herself.

"Has anyone seen my wife?" - Columbo

reply

Never mind that little detail. This was NOT filmed on Cape Cod. There is no house like that anywhere near a 'town beach'.

reply

The doctor had never been inside the house. He told Martin that he had seen Laura looking at him from the window. Martin got angry that Laura was looking at another man.

reply

I think he felt threatened and annoyed that another man was possibly checking out his wife but being a coward obsessed with appearances he wasn't gong to say anything to the doctor about it. Therefore he took it out on Laura. He also wanted to basically let her know "B***h I'm watching you" since maybe he thinks she was curious about getting to know the doctor.

But he knew she didn't have any other men in his house because one she would be to scared to and two he was too nice to her after the initial blowup. If he really felt she was cheating on him he wouldn't just forgive it so quickly. But he still made little snide comments like "Your doctor friend" and "Are you alone in here?" just to demean her and make her feel like he thought she was a liar and a whore.

reply

Also she didn't swear under her breath. She just scoffed like, "Oh my God, now what?"

reply