MovieChat Forums > L.A. Story (1991) Discussion > L.A. is no Manhattan; and Martin is no W...

L.A. is no Manhattan; and Martin is no Woody.


I know this has probably been said a thousand times-- discussed ad nauseam,-- about the similarities between this film and Woody Allen's "Manhattan." Everything from the relationships, to the way it romanticizes a city and its inhabitants -- rather tried to in this case, for it failed -- but the characters, as well as the settings are just nauseating, cheap, cheesy and absurd. I didn't like any of them, I didn't feel for them, even when the 'mood' music in the background was telling me to be sad for something.
There was nothing romantic, it was just absurd, and rather vexing. Quirkiness turns into beyond annoying here; interesting turns into idiotic and moronic here. What type of world are these characters living in?

But maybe. . .and that's a very small maybe.... it was done on purpose to show how truly empty LA is, and how all the stock characters that litter the landscape are that hollow, and there's nothing but copies after copies of the same, no originality, simply nonentities floating through the void of a pseudo-city.

Redeemable qualities? None. It wasn't even funny for crying out loud. It was just trying too hard to be deep and romantic and interesting and failing every time.




.;*We Live Inside A Dream*;.

reply

Redeemable qualities? Yes. Enough to make LA Story far, far more entertaining than Manhattan.

reply

No maybe about it. It is an intentional satire on L.A. and a funny one at that. Woody Allen never crossed my mind anytime I've watched this.


How do the angels get to sleep when the Devil leaves his porch light on?

reply

Not all humor is meant for everyone.

reply

I like a lot of Woody's stuff. Don't recall ever seeing Manhattan. LOVE LA Story!!! Don't even care if I ever see Manhattan.

reply

But maybe. . .and that's a very small maybe.... it was done on purpose to show how truly empty LA is, and how all the stock characters that litter the landscape are that hollow, and there's nothing but copies after copies of the same, no originality, simply nonentities floating through the void of a pseudo-city.


On the contrary. If you check out some of the making-of materials on the DVD, you will see that it was practically a response to the cynical ass holes of the world who feel that way.

reply

I like it better than manhattan. It's funnier.

reply

I know the top poster won't read this but what a load of bullshit on a slice of New York Pizza.

The imagined world of Manhattan that Woody portrays in many of his 70s and 80s films are about as phony as all of the stereotyped minutiae you drew on for Los Angeles. L.A. Story doesn't even attempt to mimic Woody Allen's film style and it actually pokes fun at the perception of L.A. culture itself. The hyperbolic "bad weather" segments always make me laugh.

reply