MovieChat Forums > Dutch (1991) Discussion > Ah, c’mon...5.8? You gotta be kiddin’ me...

Ah, c’mon...5.8? You gotta be kiddin’ me?


This is not a good film, it’s a GREAT film.


It’s a great holiday comedy, with a great cast, a good story, a wonderful score by Alan Silvestri, and it’s funny as hell, AND it’s rather moving at times.

For my money it’s a classic “road” and “buddy” film reminiscent of Planes, Trains and Automobiles, and after just viewing it (for about the 4th time) and coming here to check people’s reactions to it I must say I’m amazed (and frankly kind of baffled) at how underrated it is.


Ed O'Neill was as affable an everyman as "Dutch" as you're ever bound to see. Ethan Embry was particularly good as the spoiled and stuck up elitist brat that learns his lesson. Jobeth Williams was winning and had her moments as the long suffering mom, and Christopher McDonald shines in his supporting role (as always) and was a fabulous cad as the dad—what more could you want?


That said, if you’re one of the people who didn’t care for the film I’d be interested in hearing why, and if you did like it please tell me your favorite part(s) and quotes.


---------------------


I particularly enjoyed the opening sequence wherein “Natalie Standish” (JoBeth Williams) explains why she wasn’t present at some stuffy country club party last year because she “wasn’t invited”, and a bit later the part where Dutch first drives into Doyle’s school while the beautiful song “Suo Ghan” is heard being sung by a boy’s choir.


The African American woman sharing a moment with Doyle in the shelter was very touching as well, but I think the funniest part, for me, had to be when Dutch sets Doyle straight in that diner when he tells him (paraphrased) “You really are a hypocrite aren't you? A couple 'o hookers
got a set of rockets, that's okay, but everyone else who enters your station in life is scum?”







Your turn......




"Stick with me baby, and you'll be fartin' thru silk!"

reply

The only major problem I have with this movie is there weren't more people like Dutch in my own life growing up. I woulda had major fun on that trip! (of course it would have made for a crappy movie)

"Your entire life has been a mathematical error. A mathematical error I'm about to correct."

reply

Just goes to show how pretencious a lot of moviegoers are. Some claim this movie lost 'crediblity' after the car crash scene, but its just an allround great movie. Funny, with a great message and never feels forced.

reply

I agree. Sometimes people forget how good little movies like these were when they first came out and also it doesn't have all the cussing and gross-out stuff almost every comedy has today. This movie is nostalgic for me because I saw it in the theatre when I was 5. But nostalgia aside, part of me thinks that people don't want to remember how good movies like these were. I mean, John Hughes wrote this and Planes, Trains, and Automobiles. They are similar in certain ways and that film gets a 7.5 where this just gets a 5.8?? RIP, Mr. Hughes. These IMDb ratings are f-cked.

reply

I don't understand the rating either. This movie is HILARIOUS! It has so many great moments! Definitely one of my favs from that era.


"I knew you'd pick Medea over the well-being of the world... I would have." --> Finger

reply

Hell yeah, man! This is a great travelin' odd couple film in the tradition of Planes, Trains, and Automobiles and it's just about as entertaining. Ed O'Neal is always great in everything he's in.

reply

I gave it a 10 just now because it's my favorite Hughes film, and it's just as funny every time I watch it.

reply

I didn't even know JOhn Huges wrote this. Wow, now I have another favorite penned by him. I saw this as a kid so long ago when it came out I didn't pay attention to directors and writers yet. And yes, this movie is underated. Someone mentioned wanting a DVD. Last time I saw it was a few months ago at Walmart. They should still have it.







Just my one cent since I can't afford two.

reply

Yeah, I gave it a 10 just because. I liked this film. Definitely higher than 5.8~

God is real. Atheists don't exist

reply