after the end


what u think happened after they gotoff the island,you reckon the hunters got done for killing piggy and trying to kill jack???

reply

Just watched this on tv.

Piggy was dead and it was Ralph they were trying to kill. He cried at the end when he sees the marine and realsied he was saved.

reply

yerh i know that ,but thats not what i asked i asked if you think jack and the rest off the hunters got punished at all for killing piggy and trying to kill jack?
If they'd lived in england they woulda got away with a slap on the wrist.

reply

that's very ignorant

reply

What is?

reply

What is?

reply

"If they'd lived in england they woulda got away with a slap on the wrist."

reply

yeh i agree it is ignorant but its true.

reply

no, i mean it's ignorant of you to think that that is true.

reply

I still remember a couple of preteens who brutally murdered a little kid in England nearly 20 years ago. They were eventually let out and given new identities and nobody would ever know if they murdered again.

reply

I think the kids involved would have been put into some sort of psychiatrict facility. They wouldn't have been able to just slot back into their lives because the adults would be disgusted with what happened, especially since these were meant to be middle class boys, not street ruffians.

If they'd lived in england they woulda got away with a slap on the wrist.

Sadly, that's quite true if the story had been set today.


"I always pretend to root for Gryffindors but, secretly, I love my Slytherin boys."~ Karen, W&G

reply

They tried to kill Ralph, not Jack.

I'm happiest...in the saddle.

reply

I keep thinking about this actually

about the whole story,

what happens like when they all grow up and see each other at work,
will it be like

"you murdered my bestfriend when we were kids you bastard"

or will they even be able to fit back into society?

and wouldnt it be interesting to be the investigator that hears the story of what happened on that island.

also, would it be on the news?

someone should write a spin-off

I dont have low self-esteem,
i have low esteem for everyone else.

reply

i think off piggys parents finding out he survived and then was killed by some kid turned savage.

reply

Well, I agree that they would be put in some sort of a psychiatric hospital(the hunters don't even seem to show much remorse for their actions until the very end). They couldn't be sentenced to life imprisonment, but I don't see them returning to normal life.

reply

piggy didn't have parents I think. He mentions his mother was dead, and paused after mentioning about his father. He lived with his "auntie". Atleast that's what I got from the book.

reply

They were something like cadets in training I got from the movie. So you know the military or Army Cadets whatever wouldn't want this story to come to light. It would bring shame upon England as a whole. I think every single one of those kids got a badge of bravery and a warning never to speak of what happened. Piggy died on impact, so did the other two kids.

To truly create a memorable signature I'm going to need more than a hundred characters.

reply

copied and pasted from the 1963 film forum (written by me)

OK here goes...

I think Jack would grow up to be a leader, possibly Prime Minister or the like, he would do a good job of running the country but would have some very underhand dealings and would have his enemies bumped off secretely. He is intelligent and resourceful and obviously already has powerful connections in high places. He would bring his country (Britain probably) into a war that he thought we could win and would have a lot of support but it would slowly dawn on him that he cannot win, his supporters would gradually desert him, and he would be publicly assasinated by the opposition side while making a speech to bring back some support age ~50.

Ralph would become a writer and an unnoficial leader of few. He would spend the rest of his life trying to find good in mankind and die without finding it, after many years of travelling and study. He will die before he reaches 40.

Simon is already dead. Otherwise he would be disillusioned with mankind and try to bring about a following. He would be branded a blasphemer and a heretic and executed (crucified?) age ~30. (obviously this one's hypothetical, as he dies on the island).

Piggy also dead. Piggy would become one of the few politicians trying to bring about a fair and equal society, he would gather a small following but would never be very well known, possibly making it as far as local MP, no further, he would retire after many years hard work and die of obesity related illnesses age ~60. (Also obviously impossible due to his death on the island).

Roger would become a hitman for Jack's corrupt government. He would die far beyond enemy lines in Jack's war. He would take great pleasure in his job and take some sort of trophy (fingers?) from all his victims. Die age ~30

Sam and Eric would vow to stick together for the rest of their lives, but would drift apart and fit into society well, both being relatively successful in their chosen fields. One of them may snap from flashbacks and PTSD and kill someone. The other would die trying to free the other from prison age ~35, and the other would commit suicide in prison shortly after.

There are too many Little'uns (and not enough about them) to really go into depth about their future, but they would mostly fit quite easily into their previous lives after the current war ended.

No-one would be prosecuted for the murders commited on the island, as the island is not part of any country and therefore, has no laws. Some of them would require therapy but none would get it as there is a war on.

reply

lol thats really good,depressing but really good.

reply

Satanic Secrets, I can believe that.

http://www.cgonzales.net & http://www.drxcreatures.com

reply

I can't imagine Ralph not telling authorities how two of the kids were killed. He doesn't know about how the adult died but it wouldn't be too hard to figure it out. The kids probably wouldn't get much of a punishment sadly enough. I believe that the fact that they are kids doesn't excuse them from the gross anti-human behavior. Yes, they are in some kind of survival mode, but they had different options. That blond kid should definitely be tried as an adult and go to jail. The rest could use the Eichmann excuse I guess.

reply

I think what would happen, and forgive me but in this version of the film they're not from a british military academy, they're from an american one. They would be immediately put into a psychiatric institution for youths. Then by the time they reached their 21st birthdays it would be up to the court to either release them or put them in prison. Most of the boys would stay there, especially the older ones for a while. Plus with the investigations and interviews it would be a long time before they'd be released. Jack definitely would not be getting off easy, I would see him going to federal prison. Ralph would be released of course but that kind of trauma would give him problems the rest of his life. Just my take on it.

Don't try to be a great man. Just be a man and let history make it's judgment-Zephram Cochran

reply

It's an interesting question. Golding leaves the answer to the imagination of the reader. If you read the book, then you know that World War 3 has begun, and the children have been sent away from England for fear of nuclear attack. My guess is that given the circumstances, no charges would be brought against the children.

This 1990 film adaptation isn't very true to the novel. Check out the 1963 film, its much better and truer to Golding's masterpiece.

reply