I think the movie took a hit from critics because they watched it as though it were some kind of romantic comedy, not a quirky, surreal fairy tale. The movie was not intended to be taken "seriously," and only a few critics (Roger Ebert notably among them) actually GOT it.
The highly positive reactions to the movie from posters on these boards and elsewhere is a testament to the fact that there are people who appreciate it (I love this movie). And I'm very happy that John Patrick Shanley (the writer and director) has since gone on to cement his reputation as a REAL creative talent, winning the pulitzer for his play "Doubt" 20 some odd years after winning an oscar for his screenplay for "Moonstruck." Sandwiched in between those is "Joe," and hopefully the bookends of success that Mr. Shanley has enjoyed will cause critics to revisit "Joe" with more discerning eyes. It truly is a very special little movie.
reply
share