Saddest moments on the show
What were some of the saddest moments on the show?
shareThe very end of Season 7's finale, "Terminal," where Adam has to agree to remove the life-support for his dying wife in the hospital. Very tough to sit through those few minutes from what was a fine episode even without this added element.
shareAbsolutely that was the only moment that was extremely sad. Steven Hill did a brilliant job acting that scene, very hard to watch.
shareAnd it's sadder as I think about it in retrospect precisely because we, as viewers, never knew his wife, because Adam's work as DA was so much of his life. It used to bother me that they basically introduced his wife to kill her off, but it works when seeing it from Adam's perspective (thinking in those last seconds about what really matters to him in life and how she's going away before his eyes).
shareYeah we just never saw the characters personal lives, Schiff had talked about his family but we had never seen his wife. It definitely worked, it was a very moving episode.
shareHe makes a barely audiable, sharp moan when his wife dies, not bringing any attention to himself. Very good acting.
shareTwo sad moments with a common theme, albeit not as sad as the other one I mentioned above. Remember the look of sadness on Lennie's face when Claire died in the car crash at the end of "Aftershock?" And how about the similar look on his face at the end of Season 8's "Damaged" after his daughter is killed? (Orbach was really good at those facial expressions, remember it in "Dirty Dancing" after he had that tough chat with his daughter on the back porch?)
shareHow about these:
Stiff- A woman is comatose after being given spiked insulin. The last-ditch attempt to wake her fails. The woman's daughter, who is responsible for the crime, whispers tearfully "I'm so sorry, Mom."
DNR- A women is left mortally wounded by an assassin hired by her husband, who was jealous of her burgeoning career as a judge. She is in strong denial over him trying to kill her and severely depressed over being left a paraplegic who cannot care for herself. At the trial to determine if she was competent to make a decision on her life, she suffers a breakdown on the stand.
Endurance- A mother has been put on trial for murdering her son, who suffered from severe physical and mental health problems which had obviously taken their toll on her. Upon his cross-examination, McCoy inadvertently prompts the mother to break down on the stand and admit that she had watched him have what she thought was a fatal seizure, unable to bear saving him only to force him to endure the pain and suffering he was forced to live through, and actually attempted to kill herself with her son's pills so that they would both die together before coming to her senses. The woman's tearful breakdown as she insists that she couldn't bear to see her son suffer any more is so affecting that even the hard-assed, seen-it-all-before McCoy looks shaken by it. And notably, it marks one of the few times he deliberately enables a technically guilty party to receive a lighter sentence.
Savages- We see McCoy prosecuting embezzler Paul Sandig for killing a police officer, which is a capital offense. Eventually, with his guilt beyond doubt, Sandig finally breaks down, expressing remorse and tearfully begging for his life. The guy may have been guilty of murder, but it's still pitiful to see.
Mayhem- A very socially awkward but endearing man is on trial for a string of brutal murders - he's unable to provide an alibi but both the detectives and prosecutors feel he didn't do it. Eventually, his mother reveals his alibi - he's actually gay, and was seeing his lover when the murders took place, however he didn't tell the police because he didn't want his mother to find out. However, his mother already knew, but had never told him because she didn't want to embarrass him. The obviously relieved detectives go to the prison where he's remanded to get him released - only to find out he was just killed by another prisoner.
Under the Influence- McCoy is trying a banker named Bernard Dressler for killing several people while driving drunk. McCoy is going further than usual in his pursuit of justice. Everyone is telling him to back off, because Jack lost his lover to a drunk driver. Then Dressler breaks down and begs for forgiveness, and Jack realizes what he's doing. A defendant in tears and Jack pausing over a sheet of paper shouldn't be that evocative
Good post, first one that comes to mind for me is the end of Girl Most Likely, the tragedy of the accidental death and the homophobia that led to them needing to hide the relationship (and the girl taking the plea rather than being exposed as gay). Jack using the knowledge she would rather go to jail than admit to her family she was gay was also unsettling.
share