I prefer the theatrical ending to the original ending. Most people who sympathize with Veronica tend to as well, I think. I think it's also the case that people who prefer the original ending see JD as some sort of protagonist. He wasn't - he was a psychopath, and it felt very natural for the pair JD/Veronica to wind up as opposing forces, which does indeed make her a hero. Also, it's a different thing to say Veronica participated in the deaths, which is accurate, than that she murdered anyone (and frankly, they all had it coming).
The Martha shooting Veronica ending sounded great the first time I heard it, but I don't think it would be as effective. Waters said it was intended to be a final irony, but do events that weren't in her control to begin with coming back to bite her really count as an ironic moment? Provocative, maybe, but no more so than a kid blowing himself up outside the school to light her cigarette (a great touch), and not ironic.
reply
share