MovieChat Forums > Koneko monogatari (1989) Discussion > A great movie, if not a bit cruel?

A great movie, if not a bit cruel?


As a child, Milo and Otis was one of my favorite movies, and I still enjoy watching it today. It is only that I'm older, however, that I do realize that while this is still a cute, charming movie, there is a bit of animal cruelty in it that makes my heart twinge.

First being a small kitten being put into a crate and sent off down rapid water and over a few waterfalls (small waterfalls, but think of how hurt that kitten could have been). During this same scene, a bear (young by the looks of it) was put into the scene to harass the cat. While I'm sure this bear was trained, it, needless to say, startled me.

The second scene, the only other one that really struck a nerve with me (though there are a few other, smaller ones that I will not bother listing) is Milo being attacked by aggressive seagulls. It pains me to see that people would take an innocent animal and toss it amongst very aggressive, wild birds and film it being pecked and clawed.

This scene tied in with Milo being tossed over a cliff. I watched and rewatched this scene, and I've realized now that, despite how I tried to pretend it was fake, this was in fact a REAL cat they chucked over a cliff and into pounding waves.

If you watch closely, you can see the cat twist to try and make sure its paws land first, something all cats do on long falls to attempt to land on their feet. For a split second, you see Milo rise to the surface and shake his head. Milo swims to shore, more than once vanishing under a large wave before crawling out, cold, wet, and scared.

I'm amazed that most of the animals featured in this show, Milo especially, stayed anywhere near human beings after this movie was filmed.

reply

LOL yeah..I notice that. I like the end when Otis leads the charge before they go down the long road home. He runs over his little puppy at emense speed. That is one of the funniest things from any movie ever.

reply

I saw the film in Spanish it had the subtitled bits in Japanise and when i got to the Uk i got it on Vhs on Ebay as i wanted my mum to see it. On the cliff scene though when i saw it in Spanish the cat fell off the cliff was scrambling to get up the cliff again then feel off into the sea again and swam to the hut before the bear came this was cut short in the VHS maybe as it looked cruel a cat following its instincts to get onto dry land making numerous attempts to clamber up the rock. i guess it was cut for vhs as it
looks a little bad but i was amazed at what i was seeing and i watched till the end and was late for work

do un2 others as they do un 2u

reply

When he runs over his puppy, did the puppy get hurt badly?

reply

[deleted]