MovieChat Forums > The Seventh Sign (1988) Discussion > 'Casca' Series By Barry Sadler

'Casca' Series By Barry Sadler


I'm amazed no one has pointed out that the idea of a centurion being sentenced to live until the return of Jesus the Christ was taken from the "Casca" series of novels by Barry Sadler. Hollywood will take ideas from anywhere and have no shame about not crediting the source!







If you love and support Michael Jackson 100%, copy & paste this into your signature. We love MJ!

reply

Actually, Cartaphilus is a much earlier character from Western legendry and some data can be found here:

http://www.wral.com/golo/blogpost/3771787/

Did Sadler "credit the source", i.e., Western legendry?

reply

"Did Sadler "credit the source", i.e., Western legendry?"--bastash8647


Probably not, but he certainly was the first to write a popular series of novels on it. I'm pretty sure the writers of "The Seventh Sign" didn't have the initiative (or intelligence) to go research "western legendry" to lift the concept of a unrepentant centurion living out the centuries until Jesus the Christ's return. I do not give Hollywood screenwriters (or at least the producers who dictate what they write)much credit for innovation.


BTW, thanks for the link. It's a fascinating article!












If you love and support Michael Jackson 100%, copy & paste this into your signature. We love MJ!

reply

You're welcome, sorry I couldn't hyperlink it for you.

reply

Those Casca book are great. I've only read two...the only ones I could find.

And yeah, when I first saw The Seventh Sign on VHS in 1992 I thought of the casca books.

reply

I know this thread is ancient but....Barry Sadler probably drew from a book by Joseph Gaer "The Legend of the Wandering Jew" published in 1961.
The Casca" series was published in 1979. It draws various incarnations of the legend into the one book. Cartaphilus is one of the incarnations.

reply