MovieChat Forums > Mississippi Burning (1989) Discussion > There is one key error that RUINS the fi...

There is one key error that RUINS the film. Yes, completely RUINS it.


This is the error of combining historical fiction with actual historical events.

Parker took an actual event--the murders of the Civil Rights workers--and then added a wholesale work of fiction onto the end of it. He should have chosen between making a purely fictional story about the era or he should have stuck to the facts of the case. Instead he made this abortion which insults the viewer at every turn. Why couldn't he have just stuck to the true story? What about the true story was not compelling enough for this idiot? In case you think I am going out on a limb here, I quote Time Magazine's Jack E. White, Jr, a black man, who referred to the film as a "cinematic lynching of the truth." I have nothing else to add to Mr. White's sentiments.

reply

Looks like a lot of people agree with the o.p.

reply

It wasn't Parker's script. I thought he dealt brilliantly with the factually flawed screenplay

reply

Agreed. But Hollywood does this all the time.

reply

Ok so the movie may have some fictional scenes. The movie is not a documentary it is a fictional drama that offers some factual information. I read the wikipedia account of this movie and yes it says it's loosely based on an actual FBI investigation. The movie doesn't pretend to be anything more then what it is. It is a work of fiction.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I don't know the history but I thought it was a pretty good movie. Making a good movie is hard. Whatever he did worked, cinematically.

I choose to believe what I was programmed to believe

reply

This is the error of combining historical fiction with actual historical events.
No doubt about this being the worst constellation. Just wonder why we as the audience cannot appreciate half-fiction as much as we can full-fiction.

__________
Last movie watched: Mississippi Burning (7/10)

reply