Why Sell?
Did I fall asleep for twenty minutes or something? They were at the lawyer's office and when the subject of the house came up she wanted it and he didn't.
And then suddenly the couple appears at a town meeting and seems desperate to sell the place. They are so desperate that they offer to pay the town to help them.
Nowhere earlier in the movie was it indicated that this place was tough to sell or that the townsfolk might be the cause of it. In fact, when Andy and Elizabeth bought it apparently the quirks of the townsfolk were never an issue.
Plus, the first couple to show up actually liked the place long before the townsfolk started acting.
--
What Would Jesus Do For A Klondike Bar (WWJDFAKB)?