Jamie
While Vinny was a bit more my type (uh oh!), I also found Jamie way cute and sweet! That part in the bus station when Melissa is saying "Jamie...Jamie" in her sleep, and then the man next to her folds back his newspaper and it's none other than Jamie...the look on his face is just too sexy!
Also, later when he's moving his hand up her leg and she tells him she doesn't think they should get romantically involved and he whispers "Why not?" Oh, he's just way too sexy there.
I wonder why they never had kids- at least 6 years later they hadn't. Hope Jamie's "Mistuh Peabody" was in good working order, you know what I'm talkin' about Snapperhead?