I've actually always preferred the end right after the challenge. That is the climax, and I always thoguht the movie was really Kitta's quest/story more than Salo's. What is going to happen afterward is pretty evident without spelling it out and lingering.
After that there appears to a version which shortens the extra ending footage to about 3-4 minutes. Its ok. I still don't really like it, and I don't think the extra minutes are handled with as much art as they could be -- feels pedantic, but its short enough that it doesn't feel draggy.
And then finally, so far as I know at least, there is the 104 minute version with the full extra footage at the end. Depsite the fascination with that version by many, I like it the least. Yes it spells out the aftermath, but in a lot of ways I think it kind of betrays the rest of the movie to do so. Its sort of an abrupt turn. Build build build climax... and oh yes, climax does not matter. The final moment with Salo waiting for the juggers up top to come down to play, and the shot of Chen crying as he leaves are good. But otherwise too draggy and too far removed. To me that's the version that feels most INcomplete, because they start telling the story all over again, and then just drop it.
At least the shorter version has a nice clean narrative arc, and then ends once it completes it letting you use your imagination to fill in the rest. The sequence at the end with the music playing over it makes it obvious Kitta, Gar, and Lindo's character are staying, and only a fool would think Lord Vile is going to let Salo back into the Red City, so I have never really seen the great need for teasing all that out. I actually would have liked to have seen a version that does not exist, with the climatic scene, and then just the one more scene after it of Chen in the silk watching and crying as Salo trudges back out of the city to the surface. That was all that was needed I think to wrap it up.
reply
share