MovieChat Forums > The Princess Bride (1987) Discussion > THIS MOVIE SHOULD NEVER BE REMADE!

THIS MOVIE SHOULD NEVER BE REMADE!


end of story!

reply

Hear, hear!

I don't know what is wrong with the world - but I know how to fix it.

reply

Put simply, and for this reason above all else, there is quite literally, not a single person alive today in the world, that could play Fezzik. No special effect ever conceived of compares to actually having a 7-5, 550+ man with muscles the size of bowling balls playing a giant.

reply


Paul Wight aka the Big Show
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0927833/

reply

No comparison. The Big Show is listed at 7-0, 485#. Andre was listed at 7-4, 520#. Craziness.

reply

Andre was listed as 7'4", but was only about 6'10" in later life. Wrestlers are always billed as being taller than they are :-) The Big Show could do a great job of Fezzik, but The Great Khali matches the description in the novel better. He looks more Turkish than The Big Show.

reply

Close, but no cigar!

~Be patient! God hasn't finished with me yet!~

reply

Right there with you! Now, how much you want to bet some idiot in the very near future will start talking about an idiot remake, hmmmm?

... the hardest thing in this world is to live in it...

reply

they would either make it to silly or too serious is the problem

reply

I agree with everyone on this thread. There are just sometimes in the movie industry that you catch lightening in a bottle. This is one of those times/movies where it happened. This movie has such a "cult" following because of how magically perfect it is. The scenery, direction, acting, characters were exquisitely complete.

The confluence of events/actors just cannot happen again. The other problem is that because of the immense love for this movie; even if the remake was extremely well made, the current fans would never accept it. It would almost be like trying to remake The Godfather, or Citizen Kane.

reply

Yep...I would be very, very sad if anyone in Hollywood decided that a remake of this one should be done.

reply

[deleted]

Taylor Lautner as Wesley! Britney Spears as Buttercup!

Keanu Reeves as Humperdinck! Jaden Smith as Inigo!

IT WRITES ITSELF!

I have a new philosophy. I'm only going to dread one day at a time.

reply

I definitely agree that it should never be remade.
It's a classic.

reply

This is one movie I have to agree on for no remake.

reply