Ash's turn


So I was watching the Evil Dead trilogy with a friend of mine a while ago. Sadly my friend isn't as accepting of the quirky strangeness of these films, and she poked a lot of holes in them all, but the biggest one she didn't like was how, between 'Evil Dead II' and 'Army Of Darkness', Ash turns from an innocent, kinda dim reluctant hero, into a wise-cracking smart-ass who cares only about himself.

And after giving it some thought, I came up with what I think is a pretty conclusive answer, although I doubt it's what the film-makers intended.

During 'Evil Dead II', we see Ash turn into Deadite Ash twice, once at the beginning and once at around the end of the third quarter. These scenes both imply that Deadite Ash is still inside him somewhere, but something keeps pulling him back from it. First, it's the sun, but then it's Linda's necklace. The first time the demon was forced away, the second time Ash remembered who he was and fought it off.
But we never truly saw it leave, did we? There was no definite moment where we saw that Ash was alright. Even when he tells Annie 'I'm alright!', she asks him for how much longer, and he doesn't have an answer, which implies the demon is still inside him.
After this, he puts together his chainsaw apparatus, and remarks that having a weapon on his arm is 'groovy'.
After this we see Ash quip and battle his way through several monsters, and by the time he arrives in the past at the beginning of 'Army Of Darkness', he's changed into the badass jerk we all know and love.

But here's where it gets interesting.
In 'Army Of Darkness', we're introduced to the main villain, 'Bad' Ash, who calls the real Ash a goody-little-two-shoes. Ash then blows his face open with the Boomstick, and remarks 'Good, bad... I'm the guy with the gun', as if he himself is even admitting he isn't 100% good, or 100% evil, he's something of a 50/50.
And besides, 'Bad' Ash had to come from somewhere, didn't he? He came from on of the several mini-Ashes which came from the mirror shards, so we can safely assume that they were manifested by the Evil itself... or alternatively, from within Ash, since the Evil couldn't get into the mill, as we saw.
So Bad Ash is pure demon in the form of Ash, the real Ash is about 50% demon, which explains his transition between movies, from hero to antihero.
This also explains how, at the end of 'Army Of Darkness', Ash is almost willing to kill Sheila, even remarking that he doesn't care about her anymore, in the lines:
'You found me beautiful once.'
'Honey, you got REAL ugly.'
It's almost as if, once she became a Deadite, he didn't even care anymore, like he did back in 'The Evil Dead', when all of his friends were converted and he was forced to kill them.

This is why I think that the Deadite version of himself is still rattling around inside his soul somewhere, pushing and nudging him in certain directions to make certain choices, having minute influences on his personality.
So as I said, I think this is the reason behind Ash's change in character between movies, although I doubt this is what the writers intended when they were making the movies.
It's arguably the biggest happy accident in film, completely demolishing all arguments about bad writing. What do you all think?

reply

I agree with this assessment. I would like to think that all of Ash's "bad" parts were drawn into Evil Ash and became part of him when he became a separate entity.

https://www.facebook.com/pages/Unofficial-Ash-vs-Evil-Dead/466308540194451

reply

[deleted]

I like your theory OP. Personally Ive always thought that Ash, after all he goes through in the first and second films, goes kind of insane and that his new personality quirks are a result of that.

reply

[deleted]

This is why I think that the Deadite version of himself is still rattling around inside his soul somewhere, pushing and nudging him in certain directions to make certain choices, having minute influences on his personality.


This makes sense of the repeated "Klaatu Barata Nicto" joke when he says he didn't say it exactly but it doesn't matter...

I don't know if you're aware of this but I've already changed things. I killed Ben Linus.
--Sayid

reply

Exactly. By the time 'Army Of Darkness' kicks off, Ash has become a snarky, sarcastic, rude, thoughtless jerk who just wants what he wants, and the rest of the world can go and hang. He only cares about himself.
Notice that it's only after Evil Ash is created that he feels bad. When he returns with the book he's visibly upset at how he's doomed the citizens of the castle, and when Sheila asks about all the sweet things he said to her, Ash flat-out admits he was lying. He doesn't make an excuse, doesn't try to cover it up, no, he admits he did wrong. He's still a jerk for doing it, but as I said, he didn't try to hide it. He knew he had done wrong and faced up to it, honourably and with a sense of unhappiness. He wasn't happy with having to do it but he still did.
As I said, this all comes AFTER Evil Ash has been created, so I think it makes a lot of sense from this angle.

reply

[deleted]

I never liked AOD and it's cheesy humour.

HARLEYS R4 YUPPIES
(my bumper sticker)

reply

Boo-hoo, I think it's the best

reply

I agree with you. I thought it was a very disappointing follow up. The humour did not spark for me at all.


reply

[deleted]

EPISODE 9 of AVED totally confirmed this theory. The Book of the Dead said to Ash: "You're not entirely good" (or something similar).

Plus, at the very end of ED2, you can see a simulacrum of Ash's head, in its Deadite form (white eyes, evil voice, extending neck), embedded into the Rotten Apple Head. You can also spot the white streak in the hair. It means a part of the "good soul" of Ash belongs to the Evil Dead forever.

http://evildeadarmyofdarkness.blogspot.com - The BEST Evil Dead Timeline in history.

reply

I've only seen the first few episodes of AVED, but I should really catch up with it if that's the case.

reply

It looks like Ash has not changed at all since BAD ASH's creation in AoD. If something, he got worse and worse as time progressed.

In Episode 9, he's willing to cut in pieces a corpse without any kind of compassion towards the memory of the "human being" the corpse once was.

http://evildeadarmyofdarkness.blogspot.com - The BEST Evil Dead Timeline in history.

reply