MovieChat Forums > Evil Dead II (1987) Discussion > Simple answer to remake/sequal debate

Simple answer to remake/sequal debate


Both films are from Ash's point of view.
Ash (or his family) owns the cabin
Ash is a raving mad psychopath.
Ash lures his friends there and killed and raped his friends and lovers, in his own mind blaming the atrocity on his religious obsession with possessing demons who "make" you do evil things.
For some reason the magnifying class pendant is a trigger to Ash, when he gives it to a girl, he becomes "possessed" and sees them differently, then kills them.
Each time he imagines the bridge is destroyed trapping his, though it is not and each time feels he is controlled by the demon to lure in more "possessed people"
The plea he hears to "Join Us" shows that he sees himself as kindred to the demons.
The second film takes places some time later (he is obviously older), he is repeating the pattern, this time with only one victim.
However he has read of the discovery of the "missing pages" and so lures the discoverers to his cabin, weaving them in to his fantasy and the idea that these too must be destroyed, by claiming to have the actual book of the dead, he brings them in (he probably killed the actual professor too)
In Army of Darkness, Ash has gone completely cuckoo and goes on a killing spree, seeing it in his mind as some kind of holy quest.

This is how I see it anyway.

Atheism is a religion in the same way that celibacy is a sexual position

reply

Interesting theory but nah.

Horror_Metal

reply

Funny theory.

Read my website...

THE EVIL DEAD TIMELINE
http://evildeadarmyofdarkness.blogspot.com

reply

I have the better solution:



Well, this is my NEW personal canon: just mine.
It's a theory.
It's not a gospel.
It's not canon.

Hopefully you'll like it the same way I like it.

1 UNIVERSE
1 ASH
1 CABIN
1 STORY


Here we go:

THE EVIL DEAD PLASTIC UNIVERSE THEORY

http://evildeadarmyofdarkness.blogspot.it/p/evil-dead-plastic-universe-premise.html

Have fun, have a good read. I'm just a passionate fan.

Thank you so much.

reply

There's nothing to indicate any of that.

You are sin.

reply

Watch the movies.

reply

I have. Several times.

There's nothing to indicate your speculation.

You are sin.

reply

There's nothing to indicate your speculation.


So it's normal when:

1- A 21 year old scared boy becomes a 29 year old skilled and strong man within one day?
2- A cabin changes furniture, design, planimetry and location within one day?

And I could list millions of many other differences.

reply

Oh, man. The Spider-man movies must really confuse you. Three different guys all calling themselves Peter Parker?! Must be madness indeed.

In any case. I just realized you're not the OP. I haven't read your plastic universe theory, so I have no actual opinion on it.

You are sin.

reply

I haven't read your plastic universe theory


Man, do it! You're welcomed, truly. Let me know... 😃

reply

The first seven minutes of Evil Dead 2 is a recap of ED1, in a Reader's Digest abridged version kind of way. Or, alternatively, told from the memory of Ash, 30/40/50/60 years later, simply remembering it as he remembers it, what was important to him at the time - ie. romantic getaway with his girlfriend, gave her a special gift, found a tape recording, released demons, had to kill girlfriend. The rest of the details are filler, which, in effect, for the first film, they were.

Or, Raimi just needed to find a way to get this film over the 80 minute mark...

reply