MovieChat Forums > Siskel & Ebert & the Movies (1986) Discussion > Who do you usually agree with?

Who do you usually agree with?

posted 15 years ago by Dash_Rendar
6 replies | jump to latest

For each of these four pairs of "At the Movies" hosts, choose the critic whose views you most often agree(d) with. (My choices are in parentheses.)

- Gene Siskel & Roger Ebert (Ebert)

- Roger Ebert & Richard Roeper (Ebert)

- Ben Lyons & Ben Mankiewicz (Lyons)

- A.O. Scott & Michael Phillips (Scott)

_____________________________
Greedo shot first. Get over it.

[–] Jeremy03 15 years ago

Gene Siskel & Roger Ebert Honestly I can't pick I like them/agree with them equal.

- Roger Ebert & Richard Roeper (Ebert)

- Ben Lyons & Ben Mankiewicz (Makiewicz)

- A.O. Scott & Michael Phillips (Phillips)

"They're coming to get you Barbara"

[–] joseph_sobora 15 years ago

Siskel & Ebert of course!

[–] ryan-anderson 14 years ago

For each of these four pairs of "At the Movies" hosts, choose the critic whose views you most often agree(d) with. (My choices are in parentheses.)

- Gene Siskel & Roger Ebert

That's the only pair I watched regularly.....so I can only speak to them. I typically agreed with Ebert more than Siskel. (I especially couldn't understand why Gene didn't like Scarface.)

Ignoring: GameBoyFan, ibestupid, Holiday_Hobo, sharon_18, TilaMoo, Okie-from-Muskogee/boo321, NorCalNik, Nullifidian, Ben_Doval

[–] CasseroleWorshipper 13 years ago

A.O. Scott, Siskel.
I don't mean to impose, but I am the Ocean.

[–] Martin_Sloan 11 years ago

- Ebert (except Full Metal Jacket and Blue Velvet)
- Ebert (but I really like Roeper. Almost as much as Siskel)
- Mankiewicz
- Phillips, probably.

Martin Scorsese IS the best

[–] quinn-52 9 years ago

Ben is ok.. He never watches anything though! lol

I like Matt Atchity

"Concentrate on what cannot lie. The evidence..." Gil Grissom