MovieChat Forums > The Color Purple (1986) Discussion > Shug's Daddy Acting all 'Holier Than Tho...

Shug's Daddy Acting all 'Holier Than Thou' BUT....


He marries pedophiles! Old Azz 50 somethings to 14 year old girls! Sicko! Juke Joint singers are leagues better than being a pedo!

reply

[deleted]

But the Bible condemns it. They ignore that but act like Juke Jointin' is so sinful?

reply

nothing was wrong with it as long as the girls parents consented? are you stupid? its still wrong no matter how you look at it.

reply

I think the poster is writing in context of the time (as in: "society" didn't think it was wrong "at the time" as long as the parents consented).

reply

Shug's daddy was of that old mindset that Shug should have been married when she was pregnant and also he probably was embarrassed because of his standing in the community and in that shame he cast Shug out...he is lucky that he lived to repent and love his daughter! Many are never that lucky

reply

It may have been wrong but that was the norm back then. What scene were you referring to though? Something mentioned in the book? Mister wasn't 50-something when her married Celie even though he was a grown man. And I saw that he married Harpo and Sofia, too.


Live your life

reply

As loads of folk have already said, that was just how society worked back then. If someone from the early 20th century was to come here they'd probably be shocked that unmarried people openly have sexual relationships and even that homosexuality has become socially acceptable, well for the most part anyway.

The Bible does not condem this any way, Joseph and Mary were probably about that age. It is also not seen as pedophillia in our culture. If a woman is "developed" but underage it is Statutory Rape. The law does not recognise that an underage girl is capable of consenting even they actually do, they have not consented by statute, hence the name statutory rape.

I also happen to make amateur films, please check them out :)
www.youtube.com/johncswheatley

reply