MovieChat Forums > A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) Discussion > Was Freddy Krueger always meant to be a ...

Was Freddy Krueger always meant to be a killer from the start (pre-lynching?)


Most fans know that the filmmakers planned for Freddy Krueger to have been a child molestor in his backstory, but changed their mind sometime during production. It's usually taken for granted that the idea was that he molested the kids in addition to murdering them, but do we know for sure that was the case?

I ask because it occured to me that the backstory with the parents' mob justice actually works a lot better for the story if Fred Krueger did not turn to murder until after the parents burned him alive and he became a dream demon. Since he wouldn't have been so much of an active threat (most child molestors go after kids they know rather than go around stalkng random victims), the parents' actions come off purely vengeful, and it's easier to see them as being responsible for Freddy becoming even worse.

With Freddy having always been a serial killer, though, the parents actually look pragmatic (hell, maybe even heroic), like they were simply desperate to try to put an end to an active threat, and that it just didn't work in the end.

reply

I think you are probably right. As a child molester, and a very clever one, Freddy could have been active for quite a long time and had a large number of victims... With the children under his psychological control. As a murderer, it's just surprising that he got away with multiple killings in such a small area.

The filmmakers probably decided it was somehow less unpleasant to make him a serial killer and let the rest be implied.

I had a great idea for the (generally pointless) remake - Have Freddy NOT be a killer OR a child molester. Instead, have a series of killings and molestations with the weird janitor being blamed, based largely on his discovered writings and paintings - (See Henry Darger, the guy celebrated after his death as an outsider artist.) The notion is that Freddy had all these disturbing fantasies, but never meant any harm and was actually innocent. This allows for his supernatural revenge as well as having a nice surprise at some point when it turns out that someone like the Sheriff turns out to be the murderer.

reply