MovieChat Forums > The Natural (1984) Discussion > The single pitch when Max knew who Roy w...

The single pitch when Max knew who Roy was


When he makes that pitch at the end of practice he has a slight grimace and tugs at his side. I'm guessing that pitching aggravated his condition which is why he had to switch to playing a position.
Does anyone recall this being discussed in the book?

reply

Good call.

-Walked five miles to school and back, uphill both ways. No, really, I have pictures- M.C. Escher

reply


When he makes that pitch at the end of practice he has a slight grimace and tugs at his side. I'm guessing that pitching aggravated his condition which is why he had to switch to playing a position.
Does anyone recall this being discussed in the book?


I didn't read the book, but before that scene I wondered why Roy came back as a right fielder instead of a pitcher (that he was scouted for). For accuracy, they should have made Roy a left or center fielder as right field generally requires a cannon to make the throw to third base.



It is bad to drink Jobus rum. Very bad.

reply

A lot of this movie makes no sense...like how they never even saw him practice weeks into the season.

reply

When he came to the team the season was already underway and Pop would not let him take batting practice. Nobody on the team had ever seen him hit. Once they saw him hit he got playing time behind the starter, Bump.

reply

I admit I don't follow the sport, but in the movies and on tv shows, baseball players do have this thing called 'batting practice' in between games. Even someone who is benched would be expected to participate unless injured.

reply

It just doesn't make sense that they wouldn't have him practice even if Pops thought he was brought in to help him fail.

reply

After Hobbs approaches the batting cage for his first batting practice Pop Fisher says;

Hobbs, you wanna sit this one out?
Can you imagine that Judge sending me a middle-aged rookie?
I'm gonna pay his contract. I ain't gonna play him.
Never.


Pretty clear he’s never going to practice or play.

Btw- Generally in professional sports if you don’t practice, you don’t play in games (at least in the old days, until Allen Iverson came around).

reply

So, no practice gave Pops the excuse to not play him?

reply

He didn't need an excuse. As manager and part owner he can make any player decision he wants.

reply