Couldn't Get Into The Novel at All.


I just couldn't get into the novel at all. Too many flowery descriptive phrases, which slowed up the action too much!

The Webmaster
www.singlemovielovers.co.uk

reply

I didn't care for the novel, either. One thing I liked about the movie was that it cut out a lot of Mr Holloway's longwinded speeches, as well as made the ending a bit less overwrought.

reply

I liked the novel. I'd read it once several years before I saw the movie, and then after I saw it I went out the next day and picked up the book again to read.

reply

I have the exact opposite feeling. I love the novel and the prose... I didn't like the movie. Definitely disappointing.

I'm not going there to die. I'm going to find out if I'm really alive.

reply

[deleted]

LMAO. Its most certainly not an "attention-span thing", I've found many people just aren't fond of Bradbury's style.

reply

the novel is a classic example of horror fiction and transcends into a book about age, youth, good, evil. etc
there are some truly scary moments in the book that were left out of the film but overall I liked the film and they captured the tone and scope of the novel

reply

I haven't seen the movie yet but I loved the novel. The prose was amazing. I read it on my Kindle and highlighted so many wonderful passages. I am hesitant to watch the movie. I am concerned that it is too different from the book. I also don't think Bradbury's wonderful writing can be translated to film.

reply

I am hesitant to watch the movie. I am concerned that it is too different from the book. I also don't think Bradbury's wonderful writing can be translated to film.


H.P. Lovecraft is very hard to translate to the screen as well. With that said, sometimes you just have to realize that the movie is not and never will be the book. That doesn't mean that the movie doesn't have anything good to offer, though. You just have to keep in mind that it is for the most part a different beast entirely that shares a few similarities with the book. Movies are always going to change things because film is an entirely different medium than the written word. I could hate Vincent Price's The Haunted Palace for changing so much of the Lovecraft story 'The Case of Charles Dexter Ward', but instead I view it as a different story altogether with the barest resemblance to the book. I mean, there is a lot to like about Vincent Price/Roger Corman collaborations even if they stray from the source material. Salem's Lot was a great mini-series back in the 1970s, but it strays heavily from the Stephen King book as well. They are two different animals, both enjoyable for their own reasons. The same is true of Something Wicked This Way Comes. Instead of looking for a perfect movie adaption, just see the film as a good experience in its own right.

- - - - - - -
Whose idea was it for the word "Lisp" to have an "S" in it?

reply

Yeah, I would definitely put this one down as a difficult read. Bradbury was in love with flowery language and imagery, even if it did not necessarily service the story.

reply

Not flowery -- lyrical.

reply