MovieChat Forums > The King of Comedy (1982) Discussion > De Niro's best performance?

De Niro's best performance?


I think so. Anyone else agree?

reply

It's definitely in his top 5 best performances. I think his performance in Raging Bull is probably his best. De Niro has given so many wonderful performances, that in my opinion, he is without a doubt the greatest actor of all time.

reply

De Niro is a great actor, of course, but I thought the film was ruined (well, almost ruined) by him in the lead role.

Not his fault, but it was impossible to remove images from my head from some of his other films: "Raging Bull," "Taxi Driver," "Godfather," "Deer Hunters," etc, where he played the antithesis of Rupert Pupkin. (I haven't used that word in forty years, since I was in school. Forgive me, but I think it's the best word for what I'm trying to say.)

Rupert Pupkin needed to be played by an unknown Woody Allen-type actor. Steve Buscemi before he got famous. Jason Alexander before Seinfeld. Will Ferrell before SNL and his movies afterwards.

If I were king of the world, no actor would appear in more than one movie in his life, unless it was a sequel, so that a role in one movie could never clash in my mind with roles in others.

reply

Not his fault, but it was impossible to remove images from my head from some of his other films: "Raging Bull," "Taxi Driver," "Godfather," "Deer Hunters," etc, where he played the antithesis of Rupert Pupkin.


In Taxi Driver, he plays a character who has a great deal in common with Pupkin: socially awkward, something of an outcast, and a man whose personal obsession leads him to violence. The King of Comedy is Taxi Driver's comedic counterpart.

Furthermore, saying that De Niro can't play a weak loser because he was good in tough guy roles is like saying that Al Pacino should only play gangsters. If John Wayne were cast in the part of an effeminate gay hairdresser, I could see the problem because he doesn't have the versatility and range to do much beyond his strong, silent cowboy or war hero persona. That was never the problem with versatile method actors like De Niro and the rest of his cohort (Pacino, Duvall, Hoffman) in their prime. As they got older they got typecast a lot, but that wasn't true in the 70's through early 80's. I think that De Niro's performances are so good in his early roles that he truly inhabits the character that he plays. When I watch him as Pupkin, I don't think of young Vito Corleone or of Jake Lamotta, I think of Pupkin.

reply

If not HIS best, one of HIS best if not one of THE best, period.

reply

TOTALLY AGREE !!

reply

[deleted]

It's one of his greatest, because it's not a typical De Niro Role. He's not playing a tough guy or a crook, he plays a very awkward bumbling outcast. Absolutely brilliant.

reply

I wouldn't say this is his best. I'd say it is one of his most interesting performances.
I love him in The Deer Hunter.
I personally think his best performance is in The Godfather, Part 2. That is only my opinion.

reply

I don't think it's his best performance but it is my favourite De Niro performance.

reply

The Mission

reply