My personal opinion


I kind of feel it's too long, yes there is great stuff on here but there's a lot of filler IMO and it just makes the album drag. Anyways I think it should have been chopped down to one record and if it could have what songs would you have kept? Mine would have been as follows:

1. In The Flesh?
2. Another Brick In The Wall Part I
3. The Happiest Days Of Our Lives
4. Another Brick In The Wall Part II
5. Mother
6. Young Lust
7. One Of My Turns
8. Another Brick In The Wall Part III
9. Hey You
10. Comfortably Numb
11. In The Flesh
12. Run Like Hell
13. The Trial
14. Outside The Wall

reply

Disclaimer: I don't believe that The Wall needs edited down at all, even for how miserable of an album it is.

That aside, I'd rather see Goodbye Blue Sky and Empty Spaces remain and Young Lust go. Waiting for the Worms is also an essential track.

reply

I see, I think we have differing tastes, I'm more of a fan of the straight ahead rock songs while you seem to like the more operatic ones.

reply

For me straight ahead rock is Motörhead and The Ramones. 4/4 Floyd doesn't do much for me.

reply

How would they get a feature length movie out of a single record?

reply

They didn’t have to make a feature length movie, hell I’ve never even seen it.

reply