MovieChat Forums > E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial (1982) Discussion > This should've been Spielbergs first Osc...

This should've been Spielbergs first Oscar win


This, Color Purple, and then Schindlers List and Saving Private Ryan. I got a feeling the academy snubbed him on purpose until he did something they couldn't bypass such as Schindlers List.

ET is a great film and one of the few that made me cry as a kid.

You guys should check out the marathon I did on my blog for ET titled When They Arrive Undercover. You can check it out here.

http://mbmb14.blogspot.com/2015/10/when-aliens-arrive-incognito.html

reply

Even Richard Attenborough who won the oscar with Ghandi over E.T. for best picture that year said E.T. deserved to win.

"ET was an infinitely more creative and fundamental piece of cinema [than Gandhi]. Without the initial premise of Mahatma Gandhi, the film would be nothing. Therefore it's a narrative film but it's a piece of narration rather than a piece of cinema, as such. ET depended absolutely on the concept of cinema and I think that Steven Spielberg, who I'm very fond of, is a genius. I think ET is a quite extraordinary piece of cinema."

He's right. Ghandi is fine but E.T. is phenomenal on many levels. I wasn't alive then but I can't imagine how pissed I'd have been watching the oscars and seeing it get snubbed. They tend to favor the historical stuff in the academy.

reply

Gandhi was great, I'm glad it won. It should've been a split, where one wins Best Director and the other gets Best Picture.

reply

Well, just look at the name of the awarding body: "Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences". That's a fairly heady and serious moniker. So it's no wonder they always seem to be looking for fare that makes movies more serious and egghead oriented.

____________________
The story is king.

reply

What?? You're saying this cutesy thing over Jaws and/or Close Encounters Of The Third Kind? What??

reply

I agree that this should've been his first win, but Schindler's List and Saving Private Ryan are both magnificent films as well. I would've loved to see him win for all three!

reply

Any awards competition is subjective, but I do think that in the early 80s the voting members of the Academy were probably trying to keep the young upstart in check. Dude was reeling off one record breaking movie after another, and that might not have sat very well with the establishment. Plus, his stuff was "commercial". Never mind they're now all considered classics.

----
A journey into the realm of the obscure: http://saturdayshowcase.blogspot.com/

reply

Exactly, fluke. Couldn't have said it better.

Get your Detroit jukebox Jheri curl ass in this chicken sh!t chop-chop. ASAFP!

reply