MovieChat Forums > Southern Comfort (1981) Discussion > Are there really Cajuns living like this...

Are there really Cajuns living like this in the southern USA?


Let me just start off by saying that this was one of the best movies I have ever seen. Is it just a common Hollywood dramatization, or are there really isolated Cajun/hillbilly villages and towns like this in the deep woods of Louisiana or other southern US states? It may sound like a dumb question, but I am not from around there so I wouldn't really know first hand. When I watched the movie, the thought of encountering real life folk like this kind of gave me the chills. Tell you, I wouldn't want to stumble onto a place like that while on a camping trip.

reply

[deleted]

Without a doubt there are relatively remote communities that play to some extent by their own rules. It's a global phenomenon. For example, some of these people feel that certain laws and restrictions don't apply to them and their situation, especially if they feel that the rules are unjust, and they might prefer to solve their community's issues internally. That means, if you try to steal somebody's boat, you might get your ass shot at, even if it were against the law. If you get out of line, it's pretty much common practice to kick you back in, instead of resorting to legal action. There's a reason for these communities becoming close-knit: Help is always too far away, so you have to rely on your neighbors in emergencies.

Not exactly isolated (they weren't in the movie either), but still far (geographically) from "civilization". It really isn't all that uncommon either in the western world, all that is really needed is a significant distance to the nearest major city. But yes, it was just a Hollywood dramatization. These isolated communities usually are just as moral (sometimes even more) and the people often have a very clear sense of right and wrong.

----
Rated R for violence, sexuality, and language.

reply

I live in Alaska, but I'm from the South. I have relatives who don't think black people are " real people. " When I tell my friends up here about a town in Eastern Tennessee that used to have a sign up saying No N@#$%^ allowed, they think I'm kidding. I KNOW THERE ARE PEOPLE OUT THERE LIVING LIKE THE GUYS IN DELIVERANCE

reply

"I live in Alaska, but I'm from the South. I have relatives who don't think black people are " real people. " When I tell my friends up here about a town in Eastern Tennessee that used to have a sign up saying No N@#$%^ allowed, they think I'm kidding. I KNOW THERE ARE PEOPLE OUT THERE LIVING LIKE THE GUYS IN DELIVERANCE."

I'm from East Tennessee too (Kingsport), currently living in the Atlanta area. Reserviorfrog was that Elizabethton, Tennessee, where you saw the sign? - I remember a sign like that, but I thought it said "N*&^%$ don't let Sun Down catch you in Elizabethton" or something like that. I remember seeing that once when I was a kid (I'm currently 53) in the 60s. Some of my relatives are "hill people" and I am constantly surprised at what comes out their mouths when I am around them.

reply

"real" country living is becoming scarcer by the second in rural america due to suburban sprawl. for instance, where i live, just north of pittsburgh. the alleghany valley. sure i live in the city, but just a few miles down the highway and up into the mountains and your in gods country. well, that is until they build a wal mart, and then a fancey housing developement, and then a movie theater and even more housing. chop down all the woods and force all the locals out and then what do you have? white america. until black folks start moving in then they move farther out into the wilderness until there is no more wilderness left and we are all forced to live together in harmony, in say a hundred years or so :)

reply

You're right: 1 or 2 who cares---6 or 8 there goes the neighborhood

I'd rather go hunting with Dick Cheney, than driving with Ted Kennedy





reply

are there really isolated Cajun/hillbilly villages and towns like this in the deep woods of Louisiana
Uh, "hillbilly" would be Tennessee. There are no hills in Southern Louisiana, when watching the movie you may notice a swap not woods.

reply

Yes, they are there. If you'll look at a map of Louisiana, on the far western border with Texas is the largest man-made lake in the US, Toledo Bend. Used to be you could fish the whole thing with either state's license. The poachers from the Louisiana side almost ruined the fishery there. Nothing against Louisianans as they ain't all that way, but there are a lot of hillbillies/rednecks etc. that live a lot like those depicted in the movie. I know because I have relatives in both states real close to the area I'm speaking of.

There are no more friendly civilians, sir.

reply

I lived in Louisiana a couple years ago. The 'hillbillys' portrayed in Southern Comfort actually do live there. The folks in LA called them 'coon asses'.

The rule of thumb where I lived, is that if one ventures south of Toledo Bend, one is taking a risk; there is no law in bayou. Of course we ventured south of Toledo Bend, because the fishing is remarkable. The 'coon asses' keep to themselves, but they are scary. It shocks me how there are little villages in the swamps, and what's even more scary are when you motor past a random shack, and the fire pit is smoking and clothes are drying above it, but you can't see the resident, and you know he can see you.

reply

I live in Illinois but a friend of mine used to date a girl who had relatives in Louisiana. She told me once that Cajuns were pretty private and territorial. She said they were quick to draw a shotgun if you walked on their yard or hiked/drove through their property.
She gave the impression rural Cajuns were harmless as could be if left alone, but hot tempered as hell if you rubbed them the wrong way.

reply

My point is that a Cajun, Hill Billy, and Red Neck are not one in the same. A "cajun" is from southern LA, a "hill billy is from TN, and a "red neck" is from south-eastern TX.

You people amaze me with your stereotypes, not everyone from these states have red hair, missing teeth, and play a banjo.

reply

"red neck" is from south-eastern TX"

wrong...there are rednecks everywhere

reply

Everywhere, even in Asia? ...you people amaze me with your stereotypes.

reply

Cajun is an ethnicity, not a name for rednecks that live in the swamps. There's Cajun people that live everywhere in America, Luisianna's just where their roots are from. Saying that's what Cajun's are is like saying that all blacks are in gangs and live in the ghetto. There are just as many crazy hicks of English decent as their are Cajun, just in a different area in the south. It amazes me that there are people that think that Cajun is a word which describes Swamp hicks.

reply

Luisianna's just where their roots are from.
Actually, the Cajun "roots" are in Canada, preceding Louisiana.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cajun

----------
"If I've never seen it before, it's a new release to me."

reply

[deleted]

Those would be the infamous "Yellow-Necks."

reply

The most red-necks I have ever seen were in Michigan and Pennsylvania.

reply

Man I gotta go to Louisiana!!!

reply

[deleted]

Ah mosh yo haid, yo fok wi' ME pirogue...

"They sucked his brains out!"

reply

We used to travel all around the State of New Hampshire and you'd run into some "interesting" people in the deep woods. But the rule is pretty much like it is everywhere: Show respect and be kind and nothing should happen.

reply

I don't know about Cajuns. But there are rural poor people all over the United States.

reply