MovieChat Forums > Ghost Story (1981) Discussion > Not really a movie for fans of the novel

Not really a movie for fans of the novel


The filmmaker took Straub's lush, strange novel with it's Manitou and ghosts straight out of "The Turn of The Screw" and turned it into a really dull, conventional horror film :/

Alice Krige's nudity aside, this just wasn't very good.

Due to the lack of moderators, trolls can ruin the IMDB message boards. Don't feed them.

reply

Quite right. It's almost like the film was designed to drive fans of the novel utterly insane.

reply

I am a huge fan of the book. Although I thought this movie was average, I think the filmmaker definitely portrayed the atmosphere and setting spot on. I just love the snow and the internal shots of the homes. It was what I pictured when reading the novel.

reply

I agree with you guys. The film should have been a classic instead of a forgettable movie that nobody has heard of.
I thought the book was well beyond a conventional ghost story with a great deal of mystery, psychological and physical horror and a complexity of various threads that just don't play out well in the film. At the time it reminded me of some of Kings best novels. I know Peter Straub is established in his own right but this was my favorite of his as he tends to do less of the multi character universe.

reply

I haven't read the book but I thought the movie was ok

reply

In the early '80s I read all the Peter Straub books since he was equal to Stephen King, Dean Koontz and Robert McCammon at the time, but skipped "Ghost Story" because I saw this movie first, and thought the book was probably just as boring as the movie. Re-watching the movie recently, I think it's a nice time capsule of the very early 1980s era.

reply