The movie could have started at the 40 minute mark
Who else thinks that the first 40 minutes were pretty unnecessary? All those general interactions in camp, that sub plot with the bully who targets the shy boy that never gets anywhere etc.
They could have just started the movie with the counsellor retelling the story. It would have worked just as well.
This was a wrong way of creating the movie anyway: Showing the real events at the start of the movie and then the counsellor telling the dramatized legend version of it was pointless. What's the deal with the whole "they never found the body" story if we, the audience, already know without a shadow of a doubt what really happened?
They should have started with the campfire story and then gone on from there. In the end, they show a flashback of the events anyway, so they could have just extended that flashback to include the full intro scene and that's it: A nice little 50 minute film.