MovieChat Forums > The Greatest American Hero (1981) Discussion > A potentially great show that wasn't gre...

A potentially great show that wasn't great at all


It's funny how when you're a kid you remember old TV shows as something special. Years later, some of those shows hold up to still being special. GAH is NOT one of those shows.

It had poor direction. Continuity was lousy. The flight scenes were mostly canned and completely "gay" looking. There were times here and there when Ralph would do something that was "cool as heck". But it was rare. They really should have poured more effort into making this show better. My kids laugh at this show because they love the idea that a guy who can fly doesn't know how, and he screams when he tries. Lol. But I cringe at the scenes today.

reply

I don't think the show was meant to be taken seriously. It was a goofy, lighthearted superhero show. I know these days superheroes are the dark and brooding type but this show is a satire of it all.

reply

It is a spoof show. It has a title which when abbreviated spells out "gah" (actually "tgah", but I am still fairly certain that it's intentional).

The premise is; what would happen if a completely ordinary person got great powers, but no direction.

Most instances where "average people" get "powers" (or "destinies" or whatever) in comics/movies, they have a "Yoda" (X-Men, for instance) or their personalities/characters turn out to be way beyond what they themselves could even imagine (Spiderman or Batman, for instance).

Ralph has none of that. He is average before he gets the suit, and he is average when he puts it on. He was never supposed to be "cool as heck". He was supposed to be a relatable character. He was supposed to fail most of the time, like most of us would in similar circumstances.

Quidquid Latinae dictum sit, altum viditur.

reply

It was meant for a younger audience that supposedly was more forgiving of poor production values like poor SFX. Well, the suits had it wrong, because after being exposed to Star Wars and Superman kids demanded quality, only the higher ups weren't making the connection. So, they produced this show, and other like fare for young audiences who tuned in for a while, then tuned it out.

reply

What also hindered its success was the fact it had some legal issues.

Just before the show premiered in 1981, DC Comics filed a lawsuit against the production company, claiming that the series' concept was an infringement on Superman. Here's a full detail of that suit (Warner Bros. V. ABC): http://www.law.cornell.edu/copyright/cases/720_F2d_231.htm

It also didn't help that President Reagan got shot by a man with a similar last name as the lead character. The would-be assassin was John Hinckley (with a C); the lead character was Ralph Hinkley (no C). This led to a bit of an identity crisis, as Ralph's last name became Hanley, or he was simply called Mr. H.

SMALLVILLE: 218 episodes...and SuperBlur?

reply

Oh wow, I didn't make the name connection, even though I remember the day it happened. Interesting. Eh, I think that was short sighted though. I still say it was the production values. It had a strong following, but the audience that might have been wanted more.

reply

You missed the point.

This show wasn't just about its one-joke premise--the average guy mugging in a goofy costume--or the laughable flying effects, or the superhero theatrics.

The real meat of it lie in its strong character dynamic between the three leads--William Katt, Robert Culp, and Connie Sellecca. Think of it like a three-way "odd couple" scenario that just happened to have a superhero element. Katt's character was kind and earnest, Culp's was gruff and strait-laced, and Sellecca's was the heart--the glue that kept them all together.

This is the direction Stephen J. Cannell originally wanted to stick with. Only when the show diminished its character focus in favor of more cartoonish plots and elements did it lose its luster.

reply

Scrap_Iron is basically correct. Superheroes were popular in the late '70s, and ABC wanted a superhero series. Cannell insisted that the super powers had to be in the suit, that Ralph could not himself possess them.

TGAH was basically a comic drama about a bunch of often-clueless people, including Maxwell's * FBI boss. Today's kids don't like the show because they don't understand that strong character interactions is the basis of good storytelling. "Duh... Where are the explosions?"

The special effects were poor, even for their time. Movies still used travelling mattes, which were impossibly expensive for a weekly series. The flying sequences were done by a company called Magicam. ** I suspect the film elements were converted to video, manipulated, then returned to film. The results were decidedly mediocre, and generally unconvincing.

On the other hand, the stunts were the best in any TV series I've ever seen. Week after week, Katt's stunt double took a major beating.

There's no question the budget was tight. In early episodes, Ralph becomes invisible using, a smooth lap dissolve -- which costs money. In later episodes, it's done with an in-camera cut -- which costs nothing, and looks Really Ugly.

* Does anyone know whether Bill Maxwell was named after Maxwell Smart, or even Robert Maxwell, one of the producers of Adventures of Superman?

** At least three companies used this name, including one run by Douglas Trumbull.

reply

I think the fact that we are still remembering and talking about this show more than 30 years later proves that the show was indeed very good.

reply

I'm watching the pilot on Youtube right now - and lovin' it.

reply

OP,

There's no easy way for me to say this, but you're an idiot. This show was not a straight up, in your face superhero show that had a hero that did stuff that was "cool as heck". It was about a regular guy who got a silly looking suit with a cape, and how that costume interefered with his daily life. The show dealt with the human condition and he humour came from those human frailties. The chemistry b/w the three leads, Katt, Culp and Sellecca were what really carried the series, even in the bad episodes. When ABC tried to turn the series into a more cartoony traditional superhero series, that's when the ratings dropped it got cancelled.

reply

The chemistry b/w the three leads, Katt, Culp and Sellecca were what really carried the series, even in the bad episodes.


Yes. It was so fun to watch them interact. The three had a marvelous chemistry. Before Bob Culp died, I think they were all at Comic Con one year and they still had their energy and chemistry.

reply

Give me the show any day over the current superhero crap like of agents of shield and Gotham . I really didn't care that the production was cheap and that they reused so many scenes the two lead characters had great chemistry together and the show is just a lot of fun to watch and you really care about them.

reply