MovieChat Forums > Xanadu (1980) Discussion > is Sonny actually insane?

is Sonny actually insane?


I'm sure this reading of the film has been done before and so I apologize in advance for not being original if that's the case, but...has anyone ever read "Xanadu" as being the fever dream of Sonny Malone? If you read it that way, not only does it start to make sense, it actually becomes a brilliant kind of "arthouse" film...sort of like "Mulholland Drive" by Lynch!

Sonny is a frustrated artist who finally snaps when he throws the latest of his drawings/hopes out the window. The rest of the film is a fever dream he has, mixing reality and his own fantasies. The only time it becomes "lucid", taking place in the real world again, is the last scene...Sonny is standing in a mostly empty disco where he has imagined a party has been going on (I mean--just look at how Michael Beck plays his slow burn after ONJ sails off in a spray of LSD color and light--he looks like he's insane and his lithium is wearing off). He realizes at last that he's been living in dreamland all along--there was no Kira, no magic, "Xanadu" was just a club down the street all along.

Sonny sits down with Danny who is probably actually his uncle, dad or caretaker or something, then sees a waitress who bears a resemblance to the woman he "invented" (who he probably actually did see roller skating in the park or something) and approaches her.

No doubt, after the credits fade, the movie turns into Taxi Driver, with Sonny as Travis Bickell (Lembeck probably wouldn't have minded!).




Nilbog! It's goblin spelled backwards! This is their kingdom!

reply

You're kidding...lol.

Though I actually did hear somewhere that Michael Beck blamed this movie for ruining his career, seriously.

I kinda always liked this flick though -- maybe it's the 80's nostalgia, the muses stepping out of the wall mural, ELO, maybe all combined.

reply



Nilbog! It's goblin spelled backwards! This is their kingdom!

reply

Though I actually did hear somewhere that Michael Beck blamed this movie for ruining his career, seriously.
Firstly let me say that I like the film. However IMHO Michael Beck's acting is the weakest thing in it.

reply

I'm glad to have found this thread. I never believed the ONJ and Michael 'team' for a second. Beck was in his prime in The Warriors, but out of his element in Xanadu. I like the concept that it is all a fantasy dream and it would have worked better with that included. The petulant frustrated artiste just didn't do it for me. A drug dream, yes, art house.

I miss Big Band music and talented singers. Leonard Cohen is my idol. Civility, harmony, unity!

reply

I like the concept. The film should be re-cut so as to make this more obvious and re-released. Michael Beck's acting might be acceptable in context.

Oh Lord, you gave them eyes but they cannot see...

reply

He obviously inhaled too many paint fumes.

reply


Sonny wasn't insane but Michael Beck was for agreeing to be in this movie.

reply

Brilliant OP

An hour isn't an hour but a little bit of eternity in our hands

reply

It'd be an interesting take on the film, that's for sure.

reply

I really like this concept. The movie actually works a lot better with this in mind. A few clever edits & inserts could accomplish it.

The war is not meant to be won... it is meant to be continuous.

reply

I really loved the movie the way it was, but this concept adds reality to it.

reply