MovieChat Forums > Watership Down (1978) Discussion > Am I the only one who finds the 'Couldn'...

Am I the only one who finds the 'Couldn't get out' scene depressing...


...rather than scary?

Apparently people where scared by that scene, it's even listed on TV Tropes as either Nightmare Fuel, or High Octane Nightmare Fuel, and I can sort of see their point, but whenever I watch that scene, it doesn't scare me (nothing in this movie does), I just feel sad when I see the scene, as the scene does really well of showing how the rabbits suffered, and I just felt sorry for them all...

reply

Just wait for the new adaptation in 3-4 years time: it'll be even more harrowing.

reply

Sort of. It more horrifying as the scene plays out, transitioning to a sorrow after its over and you come to terms with the fact that all the other rabbits left behind are dead.

The idea of being stuck in a confined area with a group of others and slowly being gassed to death is a pretty terrifying one.

reply

No, not depressing, I find it harrowing, horrific, terrifying and sickeningly claustrophobic.

reply

[deleted]

Seriously - you think that's bad - read the book.
Was going to type that section out, but it wouldn't do it justice.

Possibly one of the best novels I've read.
Watched the film this morning for the first time in years, off the back of reading it and was shocked as to how light the whole thing was...

You know it makes sense!!!
:)

reply

[deleted]

Unlikely considering that in the book they were cannilbalizing eachother trying to escape.

"How'd ya know my name was Mac?" - Mac

reply

[deleted]

Oh, you have to. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I highly recommend it, providing you can get through some violence and the generally depressing atmosphere. But even in the darker parts, there's always a sense of adventure and hope that makes you want to keep reading, so it's not unpleasant to read at all.

I don't want to play down anything though, it sure is pretty gruesome at times. This "couldn't get out" scene is probably the most disturbing and upsetting part of it. It you thought the movie version was horrifying... well, I'm not kidding, the scene in the movie is actually pretty tamed in comparison. Here, it's just about 30 seconds... in the book, we get sentences like "And then the runs began to be blocked lower down with dead rabbits and the live rabbits tore them to pieces." and "After a long time the men finished. They took the bramble things out of the holes and the boy put the bodies on a stick."

*shivers*... well, like I said, pretty gruesome sometimes, but I still consider it to be one of my favourite books. If you liked the movie, you'll love it.

reply

It was probably the most upsetting scene in the film no matter how you respond to it.

reply