MovieChat Forums > The Big Sleep (1978) Discussion > Better than the original on ONE POINT ON...

Better than the original on ONE POINT ONLY!!!


The classic penultimate paragraph from the novel doesn't get read in the climax of the Hawks film, but it does in this one. That for me is the one triumph of this version.

It's the paragraph that includes the lines...

'What did it matter where you lay once you were dead....you were dead, you were sleeping the big sleep.'

...and makes some sense of the title of the film/novel.

reply

And what a great title it is. Probably my favorite noir title.

What's the Spanish for drunken bum?

reply

Vago borracho

"You're not a star until they can spell your name in Karachi."- Humphrey Bogart

reply

Were you...born in 96? If so, you're either too young or way too old to be on the internet.

What's the Spanish for drunken bum?

reply

Candy Clark naked is also an improvement.

reply

Unfortunately her performance is so over-the-top she needs an oxygen mask just to breath.

reply

I think the over-the-top performance was called for here, considering the character she was playing. What exactly would this woman's condition be, anyway? Hebephrenia?

reply

I believe Carmen has epilepsy.

reply

Her name is CAMILLA not Carmen!

reply

Ooooh yeah! Candy Clark is gorgeous in this!

reply


'What did it matter where you lay once you were dead....you were dead, you were sleeping the big sleep.'

...and makes some sense of the title of the film/novel.


I wouldn't call spoon feeding the audience an improvement. "The big sleep" has been used as a euphemism for death for ages.

However, since I never was a Bogart fan, I prefer this version for having Mitchum as Marlowe.

reply

I doubt this was better than the original at any point.


Its that man again!!

reply

[deleted]

Actually, the remake takes a lot of prose word for word from Chandler's novel while the original did not use all that much. The remake faithfully follows the plotline of the book thus making it understandable whereas the original is enjoyed in spite of the loose ends it leaves unresolved. Mitchum plays Marlowe closer to the character Chandler created than Bogie does since there is no gratuitous romance in the remake. As Marlowe says after making-out with the freak with the ugliest hair-style in motion picture history, "I work at what I do" or words to that effect. Which means he is more interested in doing his job than bedding whacked out women.

reply