MovieChat Forums > The White Buffalo (1977) Discussion > Interesting but ultimately a missed oppo...

Interesting but ultimately a missed opportunity


I had never heard of this one before despite being a Bronson fan. Horror westerns were very rare at this time and this one starts out rather well. The problem all the real good action and eerie atmospheric moments are lost between rather static expository scenes of poor dialogue. The story veers off course too many time. I like the idea of two men who should be mortal enemies coming together to fight a common enemy but unfortunately the movie gets lost in their efforts to find common ground through endless dialogue and hand gestures.

I think a remake is in order for this one.
Despite looking a little fake sometimes the Buffalo looks really cool, thankfully they did not have CGI at this time.

This movie is currently playing for free at crackle.com.

reply

This is one rare movie whose only equal I know is Dances With Wolves, in terms of the honest and real Indian parts.
So I grew to relish all those talks and interaction, without which it would be a much shallower movie, adding a depth and realism. I think it was a gained opportunity.
Actually I viewed the other way round to you. At first I thought the talk would be tredious, but then increasingly was not.

But what takes the grand cake for this film, which it probably stands alone in, is the no-holds-barred, no flinching away from, westernisms in almost every other piece of dialogue, which almost crack me up, but not laughing at the movie.

Yes, Carlos Ramboldi's ghost-like buff, called Spike,is an inventive masterdon piece.

Another thing. If this film was made today, it would be a comnmercial, watery mess. Like most of Cowboys and Aliens whose only culture is bacterial, that grew inncreasingly in my mouth. Except once it started to pull itself out of the slime.
This odd comparison can give an appreciation of character the witty White Buffalo has, which appears to me as almost a literary film and partly the reason for its 'failure.'

A lot depends on what you expect, of course, which can often transform a movie. Even the same one. I started with low expectations and tolerance.

reply

The dvd version is crisp and beautiful.

reply