MovieChat Forums > Star Wars (1977) Discussion > Did A New Hope actually in the long run,...

Did A New Hope actually in the long run, ruin George Lucas' career?


Up to that point, George Lucas was one of the top up-and-coming directors, with THX 1138 being a critically acclaimed cult film, American Graffiti being a huge hit that was nominated for Best Picture, and Star Wars of course took over the world. However, the production of the film was absolute hell for Lucas, being constantly stressed out and almost having a heart attack.

So for the next 22 years, he took a backseat to his movies, handing the director's job to his friends while he wrote and produced. By the time he finally came back to directing for the prequels, not only had his directing ability weakened, but he had become so rich from everything Star Wars brought him that he put himself in full creative control, which is a relatively unwise idea for any director. So while Lucas made a phenomenal movie in Star Wars, he wrecked himself in the process and then took too long to get back in the game.

And don't forget that for Episodes IV-VI, he had Gary Kurtz there saying "No, that's a bad idea - don't do it." For Eps I-III, he had Rick McCallum there saying "Ok George, I'll figure out how to do it."

That and his desire to sit in an air conditioned warehouse turned green screen, and do nothing but direct people walking from one side of the screen to the other, turning around and walking back was probably a LOT less stressful, but also a lot less interesting.

reply

Clouded by the dark side his vision became.

_______________________
Guacamole in my choos

reply

I'm not so sure Lucas was ever cut out for the sort of Hollywood grind his buddy Spielberg seems to thrive on anyway. He strikes me as being tightly wound. Had it not been Star Wars, it likely would've still only been a matter of time before he said "No mas" IMO.

But there's no question success spoiled Lucas. It allowed him to step away for twenty years, and in that time his skills atrophied while his legend grew. By the time he began TPM, there was no one to keep his worst instincts in check, as you said. He basically waited until technology allowed him to go film actors in a controlled environment and then go back home and actually direct the film on a PC.

----
A journey into the realm of the obscure: http://saturdayshowcase.blogspot.com/

reply

What did he do for twenty years?

reply

What did he do for twenty years?


He continued to produce the Indiana Jones saga and films like Willow and Radioland Murders. But he and his wife divorced right after ROTJ was released and it seems his primary focus was on raising their adopted daughter and then his subsequent two children (also adopted).

reply

That and his desire to sit in an air conditioned warehouse turned green screen, and do nothing but direct people walking from one side of the screen to the other, turning around and walking back was probably a LOT less stressful, but also a lot less interesting.

Maybe he's of the view "work smarter, not harder" ??

"He's dusted, busted and disgusted, but he's ok"

reply

George Lucas ruined George Lucas's career. With all the money and power he had, he could have been honing his directorial skills on any movie he wanted, but chose not to.

"All you have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to you." -Gandalf

reply

You're right, but i want to change your post a bit:

George Lucas ruined George Lucas's directing career.

and add this: George Lucas ruined Star Wars. The one thing the real (*) fans have been asking, over and over, is this: RELEASE THE ORIGINAL THEATRICAL CUTS IN HD. But no, he says that those versions of the movies no longer exist.

That being said:

I don't want to defend the man or anything, but he had a fantastic career. He is one of the richest men in Hollywood. And he singlehandedly changed filmmaking forever. He formed ILM and Skywalkersound. He formed Pixar. His company made the Editdroid, one of the first NLE digital editing machines. He was the man behind THX...

(*) i know there are no 'real fans', but you know what i mean.

English isn't my 1st language. I'm sorry for any mistakes in grammar, spelling...

reply

Agreed. And Lucas has to know that we will never stop asking for them.

"All you have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to you." -Gandalf

reply

Why doesn't he want the orginal film versions on dvd?

reply

He's more machine now than man. Twisted and evil.





👿

reply

Eventually everyone's flaws are exposed. Lucas is what he is. He deserves all the credit in the world for bringing Star Wars to life but his subsequent career has also shown, like you said, that he doesn't always have the best judgment. He needs strong people around him to keep some of his more problematic tendencies in check. So Star Wars didn't ruin him any more than Catcher in the Rye ruined JD Salinger.

Anybody remember that movie Willow that Lucas made in the 1980s? It was Lord of the Rings before Lord of the Rings, but by amazing coincidence it was basically just Star Wars in a medieval setting. That's all Lucas really knows how to do.

reply

Seems like along with Mark Hamill and Carrie Fisher, Lucas had trouble escaping the Star Wars (and Indiana Jones for that matter) curse.

"See? He can be a real sweetheart once you get to know him."-Fluttershy

reply

That's like saying building Fallingwater ruined Frank Lloyd Wright's career.

reply

[deleted]

Gary Kurtz didn't produce anything relevant after Empire so what's your point?

reply

[deleted]

I have a hard time saying A New Hope ruined Lucas's career when he is estimated to be worth $5.4 Billion because of it. I would be thrilled if something 0.1% that valuable ruins by career.

reply