MovieChat Forums > The Deep (1977) Discussion > A question or two...

A question or two...


I have read the book and seen the film, and I must say that the book was so much better. I tried to enjoy the film to the best of my abilities, but I have a few questions.

Who's side was Treece really on, I ask because of the sccene when he tells Cloche he will deliver the drugs to him, and then they seem opposing. What was up with that?

Next, why did Gail and David stay, was it to cash in on the treasure? They never really said. Were they supposed to be likable characters?

What ever happened to the ampules? The characters all of a sudden acted like they never existed? What Happened?

Please help me understand what BEnchley was trying to do with this film adaptation? So much was re arranged and adapted so differently that I got lost in the transaction.

Thanks.


I am considering nothing less than WORLD DOMINATION!

reply

Treece was a good guy, he only told Cloche that he would deliver him the drugs because he wanted some time so he could get the treasure. He eventually decided to blow up the boat so that the rest of the ampules whouldn't end up on the street.

I think that Gail and David were very likable characters, and they did stay because of the treasure.

Treece put the ampules in the tower above the house and armed the place so that it would blow up when someone attempted to steal them, which coffin eventually did.

I just think that you didn't pay enough attention to the movie, maybe you had a sandwich or two which distracted you. I myself kinda like the movie, haven't read the book though.

And lastly I don't think that anything got lost in the "transaction", maybe in the translation though :)

reply

Thanks. I was indeed distracted at the time of watching the film. I went back and watched it again and it all made sense. Thanks for getting back to me though. I LOVE this film like i LOVE the book. You should read the book, there is alot more there, though some stuff is different, as all books are, but hey, doesn't hurt.

I am considering nothing less than WORLD DOMINATION!

reply

Well, maybe I'll catch the book. I'm not much of a reader right now though, I hope I'll become one ;)

reply

I read the book too. I love the scene in which they put carbon monoxide in Gail's oxygen tank. Makes for a really tense scene...I wonder if It was in the TV version tough.

reply

Haven't seen the film for ages, so I can't remember if that scenes in it. As for the first post, yes Gail and David are good people. The morphine is simply a distraction to them, as it is the treasure that they are interested in. I did enjoy this film. Alot of reviews of the film seem to say this was an obvious cash in from Jaws etc.. Indeed you could think this, but the real reason is that Peter Benchley was a good author who was lucky enough to have had a story that he's written called Jaws adapted and made into a film by one of the up and coming directors called Spielberg. I'm sure I even read somewhere that The Deep was written even before Jaws, so if you look at it that way, the only cash in is that it is of a similar ocean adventure that really is infact taken from an earlier Benchley book. Either way, A few works have been adapted from his novels, mostly TV movies, which look like to me as being either dumbed down or badly acted or directed. At least with Jaws and the film we are here for - The Deep, you get to see on screen most of what appears to be the meat of his novels. The Deep is an enjoyable follow up to Jaws, if you wish to call it a follow up.

reply

Well Said, man.

I am considering nothing less than WORLD DOMINATION!

reply

Trace also makes mention that they can't leave the island as the airport is closed or something as Bisste's character did say "why don't we just leave". Nolte stayed for the treasure though so it suited him.

reply