MovieChat Forums > Second City TV (1977) Discussion > The older series are actually funnier th...

The older series are actually funnier than the slicker later series


OK. This ought to fire up some people. But I think having seen them all together again that the admittedly cruder early series of SCTV were sometimes alot more funny than the later (NBC) series even though they obviously had perfected their hair, makeup, sets, production values in general to a much higher degree by then.

It just seems like sometimes they were more concerned with making the sketches LOOK good than actually writing funny things for the characters to say. This isn't to say that there weren't very funny sketchs in the later series either. I thought the Godfather episode, the Christmas episode (especially Candy's drunken monologue on "Street Beef") and CCCP-1 episode are all hilarious.

Now in the case of the late great John Candy though he could save any scene just by being himself. He might have a turkey of a script to read but he could just say something completely off the cuff and screwball and make the others look at him like "What the *beep* and it would save the scene.

Also the earlier series weren't saddled with having to fit in those musical groups which was always the worst part of the show for me. I suppose if you liked the act then it was entertaining and I knew they had enough trouble writing 90-minutes of material each week so being able to eat up 12 minutes or more of time with a couple of musical numbers probably was appreciated by the writers.

I still like what they were able to do on such a shoestring budget though in the original series. It's funny in it's own simplicity.

reply

I agree and I think a lot of "SCTV purists" and hardcore fans do too.

The humor in the early episodes I find to be more mean (a promo were Floyd makes fun of Earl for getting raped in prison is a great example of this), anti-social, and a bit lower brow. All of which I would say has to do with having Harold Ramis as their head writer at the time.

Come to the board for Jon Vitti!
http://imdb.com/name/nm0900140/board/threads/

reply

I have with that. THe earlier episodes everyone was so fresh and enthused, but the later shows it seems they were just plain tired. Hmmmm

I'm not trying to be annoying...it just always works out that way.

reply

I don't know if this would have affected the writers and players or not, but in the early years of US syndication, Second City actually competed with SNL in some markets.

I remember where I lived that the local ABC affiliate ran the series opposite SNL much like Mad TV runs nationwide today.

After NBC bought them up, I have a feeling that the network didn't want them to outshine their "Made in America" product.

But then again, I love conspiracy theories...

reply

Yeah the earlier stuff was great, especially season 3(well thats in the middle)! Don't sleep on season 6 tho still. Its too bad we won't see anymore complete seasons on DVD since the volume 4(season 5,SCTV's least funniest season) did'nt do so well in sales. Next will be "SCTV:the early years" with 3 episodes from season 2 and 12 episodes from season 3.

IMDB's most overlooked poster,giving you true posts since 2001R.I.P. J Dilla

reply

[deleted]

They all made the show, Harold Ramis was great but he cracked-up alot in sketches. Even his guest appearance in season 5 as Crazy Legs you can see him crack-up.

IMDB's most overlooked poster,giving you true posts since 2001R.I.P. J Dilla

reply

[deleted]