Death of Diana Hyland


I just finished watching the first season of Eight Is Enough a couple of days ago.As far as I know I watched practically every episode of this show when it originally aired, but that was a long time ago and I can no longer remember everything about the episodes. That said, I am absolutely shocked and saddened at how the death of the late Diana Hyland was handled. Maybe the producers address her death in the second season - I really can't remember, but if they did it was too late.

Miss Hyland died after only five or six episodes were made. Instead of the show just addressing her death, they totally ignored it. Diana's name was taken off the opening credits with no explanation given and then her character Joan just vanished from the Bradford household as well. I thought the producers/writers ignoring Diana's death was very disrespectful. After Diana died it was like Joan never existed. There was no explanation at all as to where she was. All of a sudden Tom's bed is empty with no explanation. The writers could have said Joan was away on a trip and later that she died in a plane crash or something imaginative. As much as I love the show, watching the episodes after Joan's death is like being in the twilight zone.The kids are all wandering around as happy as a lark and not one asks about, or mentions their mom. Tom is also going about his business with no sadness that all of a sudden his wife isn't there. The way Diana's death is handled on the show is all very disturbing and disrespectful. Joan was an integral part of that show at the beginning and she deserved a better than she got!

reply

I remember an episode, Halloween I believe, in which one or more of them is trying to comfort Nicholas and he says something like his "mom was a good mom and good moms just don't leave" their kids.
There was also a Christmas time/type episode in which Tommy was upset because it was his year to receive a special Christmas gift from their mother.

I don't believe they knew how to handle her death and especially how to write it into a series watched by children. It was a different time then and children were more innocent.

reply

I remember that episode. The note was found in the cookie jar or something and Tommy read it and it was from his mother or something. I remember seeing the repeat too.

reply

In their original airings, Joan was said to be off visiting a relative who was expecting a baby, in those first season episodes in which she did not appear. Diana Hyland even recorded voiceovers for a few episodes, and Tom and Joan had a few phones calls.

When the show reran in the summer of 1977 before the start of the new season, ABC only reran the episodes in which Hyland didn't appear, in an effort to help viewers adjust to life without Joan. The episodes were re-edited to remove mentions of Joan (and in some cases, new material was shot to replace the Tom/Joan phone calls). And a new intro was pasted on to these episodes, one that didn't include Hyland.

Unfortunately, the DVD release as well as the current syndication package use those summer of 1977 re-edits, as opposed to the original versions (we had a thread about this issue a month ago).

reply

[deleted]

I definitely remember the Christmas episode which dealt with it some. I remember Tommy being extremely upset and then he received a card, I believe, from his mom which he read aloud surrounded by the rest of the family. I remember that he cried while reading it. Very sad!

reply

Didn't Tommy find a present from his mother in the kitchen cabinet for that Christmas episode? Its been a long time, but I am pretty sure thats what happened??

reply

David's girlfriend found Tommy's gift from Joan. She handed it to Abby, who thought it would be better for Tom to give the gift to Tommy.

reply

That part definitely had me in tears.

reply

I'm pretty sure it was a book of poems by e.e. cummings.


Roland, that's a lilac bush!

reply

I thought it was NIcholas who found the present. I remember Tom saying about her buying Christmas presents well in advance, that he had bought one for one of the girls three days after the previous Christmas and gave it to her the following Christmas and she still cherished it to that day.

reply

That is very strange that they would use the summer re-edits instead of the original episodes with Hyland's voice for the DVD episodes. I wonder if removing her voice from the syndicated (and hence, DVD) episodes had something to do with legal issues, as well. Maybe the right contracts were not in place to use her voice in reruns, or maybe they didn't want to pay her estate residuals for more than the four episodes.

reply

Joan's death was addressed frequently in the second season. In one episode, Tom reflects on the darkroom he had built for her. In the mortgage burning episode, he makes a speech in which he expresses his sadness over Joan not being there. In the episode in which Tom marries Abby, both Nicholas and Elizabeth deal with Joan's death in different ways, and in the Christmas episode, as noted elsewhere, Tommy is shown dealing with her death and, at the end, receives the book of poetry that Joan inscribed to him.

When they did one of the reunion movies -- the one dealing with Tom's birthday -- Abby makes a large card decorated with family photos. One of those photos is of Diana Hyland and Joannie thanks Abby for including a picture of their mother.

As for the first season, there likely wasn't time to address her death, as television shows are produced on tight schedules. I imagine that, when Diana Hyland died, those involved with the show were quite shocked and saddened and not sure how to handle it, so they quickly wrote those scenes mentioning that Joan was out of town.

reply

I also remember an episode where Joannie is having a hard time connecting with Abby and Abby confesses that Joannie reminds her a lot of Joan so she (unconsciously) kept a bit of distance from her.

reply

I remember that episode with joanie...and the christmas episode with tommie was heart breaking, I remember that episode made me cry and cry...

reply

Yes! Graduates (the ep when Joannie is graduating college and Elizabeth is graduating high school). That was a VERY good episode.

Oddly, as Abby always felt Joannie reminded her of Joan (or what she knew of Joan...and maybe Joannie was supposed to physically favor Joan)...I always thought Joannie and Abby favored one another (Because Laurie Walters and Betty Buckley favored some) and that is why in season 2 they lightened Laurie's hair so it was not so close in color to Betty's; and vice versa in later seasons when Laurie's hair was a little darker, they lightened BEtty's hair some.


“Success is nothing without someone you love to share it with” –Brian to Tracy in Mahogany

reply

It was heavily addressed in the Christmas episode with Tommy missing her and Tom presents him with a present from her before she passed away. EVERYBODY watching was in tears.

Her death actually made the show. No one was watching it before then. We started watching it to see how the show dealt with her passing.

reply

Her death actually made the show. No one was watching it before then. We started watching it to see how the show dealt with her passing.


Not true. The show was already popular. Her death was not the reason people watched Eight is Enough.

reply

Twas.

reply

Eight is Enough was a top 25 show in its first season, while Diana Hyland was still alive. And I remember watching it during that first season before Joan Bradford died.

reply

Somebody posted a link to this article in another thread (http://worldaccordingtomandy.blogspot.com/2012/04/why-older-shows-have-trouble-holding-up.html), and I think it sums of one aspect of this discussion nicely (that is, how the Internet and social media make us pay more attention to these changes).

Another example that happened around the same time was when Jim Davis, who played Jock on Dallas, died unexpectedly. He was explained as being away for a while, and then he "disappeared." The whole issue just lingered for about a year on the show, even though viewers knew Davis had died. Back then, it seemed like that was just one way they decided to handle it, especially if it was early in the series (the case with Hyland and Davis), and they weren't sure if they would recast the role. Dallas producers didn't recast Jock, but they did have someone show up claiming to be him a few years later, so they were able to use the mystery to their advantage. With Eight is Enough, I think they were still trying to keep the show relatively light, with a focus on family, so it would have been difficult to have a death in the fifth or sixth episode.

They previously used the "character is away" storyline more often just as a stalling tactic.

All that said, it seems pretty unbelievable that Joan would die in a plane crash while on a freelance assignment. As I recall, she had just started her freelance photography business in her next to last episode, but she's already flying on assignments?

reply

They never said how Joan died. All we knew was that it happened quickly because Tom Bradford later said that he never had a chance to say goodbye to Joan, so she clearly didn't die of a long illness like cancer, the way Diana Hyland did in real life. I assume something like a heart attack.

The producers handled it the right way. They did the voiceovers with Joan in the latter part of the first season - it's a shame those versions of the episodes are no longer available, though I do remember seeing them in syndication in the early 80s. If the syndication package/DVDs included those original edits, there would be no reason for this thread, because people would see that the death was handled sensitively. They mentioned Joan during the first season episodes where she was absent, and then immediately addressed her death at the start of season 2. They continued to talk about her loss through the final season (her parents come to visit and it's clear that her father has had trouble accepting her death).

reply

Diana was taken too soon.

reply

I disagree. She died after the first 4 episodes and they didn't know how to handle it. So they continued 9 more season 1 episodes and Season 2 began with Abby meeting Tom. At this point Tom talks about Joan and then that later episode where she bought Xmas gift to Tommy before she died. I don't know what you wanted them to do, maybe handle it like Roseanne? I think I only began watching the show in Season 2, so didn't know the backstory 'til later.

reply

Ignoring This Does Not Make It Go Away: This Is Sort Of Running Away From The Problem/Issue.
I Learned About This After My Mom Another Joan Had Passed-On In December 20th 2001. And The
Brown household Was Rocked By This Death No Matter How You May Realize This. After Diana Had Died
It Was Like Joan Wells-Bradford Never Existed. Would They Do That To My Mom Joan Ellen Brown If This Was
A Cast Member. I Suppose Yes: And Would Be Considered So Lousey.

reply

I don't know the episode but there was an incident where Nicholas was lashing out and they realized it was over his mother's death. I think the Dad talked to him about it while he was up in the tree

reply