MovieChat Forums > All Creatures Great & Small (1978) Discussion > Sherlock Holmes TV Show vs. All Creatur...

Sherlock Holmes TV Show vs. All Creatures Great and Small


Which was better? Jeremy Brett really does a good job showing Holmes virtues and vices, and Christopher Timothy really does fit James Herriot.

So, which show you like better?

Both shows ran on a long time, and both had vicious villians the hero must face or lose his job!

Just kidding.

And never forget today, that you are from...Old...Virginia!!!

reply

[deleted]

Lol, not even possible to compare.
All Creatures took place long after Sherlok timeline wise, All Creatures is based on a true story, Sherlok is a detective series...

Both great, but not even on the same ocean let alone boat.

reply

My sentiments exactly, you are comparing apples and oranges. You are talking about fictional mysteries from the late 19th to early 20th century vs a dramady adaptation of real veterinarians in practice in the countryside from just before World War II to the Korean War. Both shows are great, but there is nothing to compare one with the other.

reply