MovieChat Forums > Keoma (1976) Discussion > GREATEST WESTERN EVER MADE?

GREATEST WESTERN EVER MADE?


KEOMMMMAAAAAAAA!

reply

Uh no. The music is terrible, doesn't fit at all for a Western. Also it has to many 'late 70s/early 80's' slow effects. The story is a bit cheesy.

Overall it's ok to watch but far from a masterpiece.

reply

could'nt disagree with you more. I love it it's my favorite western and i've seen them all, Leone, Eastwood, Corbucci, Ford... :-)

reply

Not the greatest. But among the best.

reply

[deleted]

Yeah, I really don't get the love for this film and I've been watching these films for the last 30 odd years so no newcomer to them.

reply

[deleted]

Maybe not the greatest, but awful damn good just the same. The story packs one hell of a powerful emotional punch and Franco Nero was totally bad-ass in the lead.

I'm a totally bitchin' bio writer from Mars!

reply

I think you'll find DJANGO is the best ever! its genius, nero is even better in that.

reply

I liked Keoma very much (probably best western I've seen), but Django was not as good. It was good, but not that good. Slightly overrated, Django loses some of it's power in the scene they (SPOILER!) rob the gold from the fortress. It destroyes the mysterical parts of Django's person :/

reply

I think for me it could be the best non-Leone Western.

reply

Django was and is hugely over-rated. Django Kill with Tomas Milian is far better

reply

'Django Kill' was a great movie, even though I do not think that 'Django' is overrated. 'Keoma' is also a great movie though I am not into the singing (hearing the instrumental tunes prove that the music is actually pretty great in itself though).

As a side note, I get sick of people saying ''best non-Leone'' western or spaghetti western as if he is the definitive best in a genre with hundreds upon hundreds of directors. It is like saying that 'Double Indemnity' is one of the best ''non-Huston'' noir movies. It is, quite frankly, a little ridiculous. And I personally find movies like 'The Big Gundown' with its deeper political themes than in any Leone film to stand on its one as one of the best westerns ever made and not just ''one of the best NON-LEONE spaghetti westerns''. Call me old fashioned but I judge movies by their own merits and do not ignore the contributions of less-mainstream directors; by mainstrean, I mean the directors American critics declare to be the best, such as Leone, whilst ignoring others such as Corbucci, whose film 'Django' was a bigger hit in Europe than 'A Fistful of Dollars', or Kobayashi whose movies rival and often surpass those of Kurosawa.

Formerly KingAngantyr

reply

One of the better non-Leone spaghettis. Leone aside, I would rank it just below THE GREAT SILENCE, on par with DEATH RIDES A HORSE, and slightly above the likes of DJANGO or NAVAJO JOE. My appreciation:

http://juntajuleil.blogspot.com/2009/05/film-review-keoma-1976-enzo-g. html

reply

[deleted]

A case could be made that it is. But although 'Keoma' may be my favourite and definately one of the best there are other great Westerns out there such as those by Leone, Peckinpah, Corbucci and Ford that you could also make strong cases for.

Whatever the case 'Keoma' is a fantastic film and my favourite Western.

"Nothings gonna change my world!"

reply

KEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEOMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMA!
I loved the soundtrack and I dig this movie.
Franco Nero - Legend

reply



Tribute to Keoma:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4yUfTOxKI60&feature=related

reply

Yeah I just watched this tonight for the first time and I agree with the poster that thought the music was horrid. Not only was the singing hideous and out of tune, but it also spoiled the plot at every turn! The film would certainly rank among the best spaghetti westerns ever if it had just had an Ennio Morricone score instead, haha.

reply

The movie is great, same with the soundtrack. Haters gonna hate.

reply

1. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
2. The Assasination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford
3. For a Few Dollars More
4. The Great Silence
5. Once Upon a Time in the West
6. Dead Man
7. Keoma

reply

The Good, The Bad and the Ugly, A First Full of Dollars and the monumental Once Upon a Time in the West are my favorites.

reply

Not even in the same league as the Leone Westerns or Unforgiven.

reply

It is probably the most stylish, beautifully designed and photographed Western ever made. The music and the singing are awesome. The woman singer has an amazing range and colouration in her voice.

reply