MovieChat Forums > Family Plot (1976) Discussion > Family Plot's subway sequence

Family Plot's subway sequence


Can someone please describe what this never-filmed sequence or scene was to have been like?
In Hitchcock's Notebooks Dan Auiler, writing about Hitchcock and Ernest Lehman, says: "For several drafts of Family Plot, Hitchcock had tried to include a subway sequence in the film. The pair could never work out a proper excuse though for the sequence -- so it was out."
That's all I know; if you know anything else about this, would you please tell me? I'm reminded by this of the famous idea for an automobile assembly-line scene which never made it into North by Northwest.
Finally, are any of Family Plot's scripts, scenarios or other materials available on line? Or are any such materials available in print?
Many thanks.
Stuart Gardner

reply

Please, anyone?

reply

[deleted]

I attended a seminar at which Ernest Lehman, the screenwriter of this film, indicated that he and Hitchcock indeed tried to get a subway sequence into "Family Plot." As the film was to be made in San Francisco and Los Angeles, the idea was to film in the then-new Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) system in San Francisco.

Lehman said the scene was removed from the script mainly because it would cost too much, and replaced with the car scene.

I wonder: were Madame Blanche and George Lumley to get trapped in a speeding subway car or something?

Lehman also noted that the runaway car sequence was devised in some ways to "fix" problems that Lehman and Hitchcock always had with the "drunk drive" sequence in "North by Northwest." Key: removing all shots of the car hood from the POV angle, so that the road simply rushed directly into your eyes, with no hood in the way.

reply

I just noticed that I never thanked you for this!
I'm very sorry, and I can't imagine how I overlooked this.
Thanks very much for your information.

reply