Read the book



The book by Boyington is a damned good read. The man definitely had problems with drinking and this isn't glossed over. It details his exploits in China with Chenault as well as the Pacific war and his capture by the Japanese. I tried watcing this show but the gross inaccuracies and hamminess made it unwatchable for me after reading 'Baa Baa Black Sheep.'


-- Do you have any tobacco?

reply

[deleted]

I tried watcing this show but the gross inaccuracies and hamminess made it unwatchable for me after reading 'Baa Baa Black Sheep.'
Actually those inaccuracies were endorsed by Pappy Boyington himself much to the disappointment of his fellow former squadron members. When asked by the media and other people if those things on the TV series happened, he didn't deny them and said they were true!

I loved the book by Pappy and I agree that it was a great read. While he didn't gloss over his drinking problems, he did gloss over a lot of things about his exploits.

Read, "Black Sheep One: The Life of Gregory "Pappy" Boyington" by Bruce Gamble. It's also a great read and is an even-handed biography of Pappy's life before, during, after the war and until his death in 1988.

reply


I've known some combat vets who gloss over the entire war, actually. What were some of the things he skipped?

-- Do you have any tobacco?

reply

I've known some combat vets who gloss over the entire war, actually. What were some of the things he skipped?
They are numerous. But the big one I'll tell you is his shoot downs while a part of the AVG, "The Flying Tigers."

I think he got in two or three kills, instead of the five or six. The other kills he claimed were aircraft that were on the ground---something that doesn't count as far as air victories. But he claimed them anyways.

Joe Foss is really the top Marine fighter ace of the WWII Pacific Theater as a result, but HQMC refused to revise that.

Read the Bruce Gamble bio on Pappy and you will find more.

reply

okay i read a book about the squad and some people really messed up big time. like for example did you know when the black sheep were formed and given the vmf-214 designation that there already was a squad by that name? also boyington probably inflated kills. but that is no different. almost all pilots inflated the number of kills they got. records from the US and japan after the war did not add up. but we know that both sides probably inflated kills and tried to minimize losses. for example say a aircraft got hit and went low to escape. well the other side sees a plane descending with obvious damage probably thinks it is a kill. now i still respect all the pilots the same. fighters may ahve got most of the press attention but bobmers are what really did most of the damage.

reply